Sal's Pizza Bar — Restaurant in West New York

So this place came back to life after dealing with fire damage from almost a year ago. Sal's pizza was never that great before the fire. The pies were often misshapen with Inconsistent bakes. After the major overhaul, l was hoping Sal's pizza quality would also received a makeover. However, the pizza is still mediocre: thick crust that tastes like corrugate. The bake is still inconsistent. There are sides that come out burnt while other sides are just underbaked. Perhaps the oven needs to be cleaned? To make matters worse, the prices on all the food went up significantly. I remember when pizza pies a few years back were around $13. Now they are over $17. The pizzas also feel like they shrunk in size. Despite, the rating, it's clear that this place won the hearts of the locals throughout the decades is...

I’m 18 and home alone and I called for delivery and the delivery guy gave me a bit of attitude for not giving him a tip since delivery was free. Made me feel bad after he stormed out until I realized that tips are OPTIONAL. I’ve been a costumer since I was born. I remember as a kid I even made pizza there for a school field trip. Please keep your staff in check or I’ll find another pizza place. Which would be a shame since the pizza here...

Was in NYC for a family wedding. One random night my family and I were starving for some pizza and we came across Sals. WOW!!! I was thoroughly impressed with the pizza quality. The place is a bit small, but the service and food was AMAZING!!!!! I had a chicken bacon ranch pizza and a pepperoni pizza, both hands down best pizza I’ve had in NY! My family can concur since we came back 2 days later to get some more. Nonetheless, WE...