I'll Second That Resale & Consignment Store — Local services in Indian Trail

I always leave with a smile whenever I visit I’ll Second That! From the moment I walk in, Melody greets me with genuine warmth—it truly feels like visiting a friend, not just a store. This welcoming atmosphere is one of the many reasons I keep coming back.

The prices are thoughtfully set and genuinely fair—I’ve discovered some real gems without breaking the bank. The constantly changing inventory means there’s always something new or unique to find.

Scheduling appointments in advance is a breeze, and I always feel well-prepared for a smooth and stress-free shopping or consigning experience. The store maintains a welcoming, no-pressure environment that makes every visit enjoyable.

Overall, I’ll Second That combines warm customer service, great value, and seamless planning—making it a standout consignment destination. Highly...

Recently listed our home for sale in Indian Trail and left many items there for consignment to declutter home and simplify move. Now that we are living more than 2 hours away we have been waiting for "the check is in the mail" for months. Items were sold and we were told in October that check was mailed, then 2 weeks later we were told no the checks were not mailed because owner thinks her local post office is stealing from her. Then we were told she was mailing a check in a plain envelope with her handwritten return address so post office would not know she was mailing a check??? Now a month later still no checks and she does not answer phone or return calls for messages left on her voicemail.... Beware leaving consignments with these people, we would have been better off donating items to a...

I have bought several decorative items from this store over the years. Most recently a gorgeous hand painted mirror that would have easily been over 100$ anywhere else. They have a great selection of items at a very reasonable price! And they’re always full of lots of things to look at, very friendly and happy to assist if you need it. I had my young daughter with me the other day, and they were so sweet and friendly to her and they made her feel like a “grown up” shopper. She was able to buy her sister some earrings with her own 3 dollars which pleased her. Great local...