Eileen's Colossal Cookies — Local services in Kansas City

Man.. I really wanted to like this place. It's location is great (right by Dollar Tree, Hobby Lobby, and post office). I went in the other day with my two kids to check it out and got two sugar cookies to take home for a treat. My oldest took a bite and immediately spit it back out (which NEVER happens), and sadly I did the same when I tried it. The icing/frosting was funky tasting. Later, a friend of mine told me that Eileens' uses almond extract and that's what gives it that weird taste. Maybe we'll try a non-frosted cookie next time, but we will definitely not be buying any more...

Got the package of a dozen sugar cookies with the white icing and sprinkles on top. The icing tastes almost like a bad cherry flavoring and has a horrible aftertaste but underneath the cookie was good once I could taste it. I tried a second cookie and scraped all of the icing off and it had still just given it a nasty flavor So I threw the rest of the 10 cookies away. If I try their cookies again I will not be getting anything iced. I do not know what type of icing were on those but it ruined the cookie. I have never met a cookie I didn’t like...the icing was...

I can't say enough good stuff about Eileen's in KC north. First of all, cookies are always a good idea and theirs are delicious. My kids love to get cookie cakes for their birthdays and Eileen's is the go to place. That's what brought me in this time. Due to some recent changes in plans, I found myself needing a cookie cake on short notice. Normally I would order ahead but circumstances prevented that. I showed up and the super friendly staff at Eileen's helped ensure my daughter would have a great birthday. Thanks to all at...