Sag Harbor Variety Store — Local services in Town of Southampton

Absolutely PISS POOR experience. My wife went into the store shortly before they closed only to be told twice in a matter of 60 seconds they were closing soon. In fact the sign was marked closed prior to the store actually closing. They then preceded to talk about my wife in front of her. At that point she left and I came in to address the issue. The store employee looked at me when I walked in and said “You’ve got 30 seconds.” This place cares a lot more about closing before they actually close than being kind and helpful to its customers. You couldn’t pay me enough to walk back into this...

The Sag Harbor Variety Store has basically everything you could be looking for, candy, lampshades, an extensive sewing/knitting department, crafting supplies, toys, games... No cigarettes, and no stamps these days, but if you’re looking for anything else stop there first. They’re also locally owned, so buying there helps keep what has been a Main Street Staple for decades...

Tried and true, not much has changed here in the 25 years of my stopping in. They've got a wide selection of pretty much everything you could need. Lots of vintage toys, puzzles, cool crafts, and the type of toys kids these days don't know exist.

I had to buy a store t-shirt! They're simple and not...