I'll start by saying I've been here three times. I enjoy the food very much (if you don't want to read about the full experience and want good food even if you risk meh service... Just go because the food is amazing). The first time I went I got the peacemaker poboy w/mac and cheese but I think they mixed things up and gave me something different. Wasn't mad about it because whatever I got was also delicious and I'm not a picky eater.

The second time I went was for my birthday. My partner booked us and two friends the boil as a surprise (quite a while in advance). My birthday is in December and it was packed between other patrons and two holiday parties. Although we had a reservation the staff seemed unsure of what to do with us when we arrived and stuck us at a very tiny table that they pulled from elsewhere right next to the door. It was so cold with so many people coming and going we had to request a space heater (which broke). It then seemed like they completely forgot that we booked the boil because we were asked if we were ready to order. Then it was a mad dash to change the table setting to prepare. We now think that our boil wasn't prepared properly because after a recent visit we noticed that another table's boil smelled so much more seasoned than the one we had that night. Supper took so long my partner had to cancel the remainder of the plans for the evening. We got a round of complimentary drinks but by the end I was so cold and miserable from the whole experience I declined my complimentary dessert and wanted to go home.

We went again this past Thursday night. There was one table who got a boil and maybe two or three other tables. Not super busy. This is where I realized the first time I did not get a peacemaker poboy the first time because I ordered it again and it was completely different (although delicious). Our server, however, I hope she was new because the service was terrible. Long waits while they focused on the table who got the boil. My partner's drink was empty for half the meal and never offered to be refilled and then when I finally asked for more water it never arrived. She didn't even know what the dessert special was even when she came to our table to ask if we wanted dessert. Also I was really excited about the cucumber salad but they didn't have any. Which I understand happens but I was bummed nonetheless.

Overall I will say maybe I've just had terrible luck because others seem to have amazing experiences and the food is outstanding. Like. Really freakin good. Except the side slaw. Unless I got a meh batch but it wasn't worth it. Get the mac and cheese.