Fine Fellows Creamery — Restaurant in Cape May

Obsessed with the decor, told my husband it was like a manic dream sequence set in the 80’s. Rainbow floating lanterns and bright pink walls. Also the menu items are named after 70’s and 80’s pop icons - pretty fun!

My husband had some sort of pb&jelly shake and I got the vegan mint chocolate chip. Husband downed his shake rather quickly, and I cannot remember the last time I had mint chocolate chip ice cream! I cannot have dairy anymore so last time I had dairy ice cream was probably more than a decade ago. I asked the owner (?) what base they use and he said coconut cream! Usually you can tell because coconut has a pretty distinct flavor (which I don’t mind but some do) and I’ve tried every dairy alternative ice cream under the sun and when I tell you this tasted like the mint chocolate chip I remember as a kid, I’m not kidding!! He was very sweet and seemed happy I asked.

Also kudos to him because I was obsessed with his sparkly nail polish and the fact that he looked like a young Pedro Pascal! Next time we are in Cape May I...

Fine Fellows Creamery is such a gem in Cape May! We stopped by during our minimoon and it was the perfect sweet treat after strolling the Washington Street Mall. The shop has a cozy, welcoming vibe, and the staff were so friendly and patient while we looked through all the delicious options.

The ice cream itself was fantastic — creamy, rich, and full of flavor. The portion sizes were generous, and you can tell everything is made with care. It’s the kind of ice cream that makes you stop mid-bite and say, “wow, this is good.” We loved that there were classic flavors alongside some more creative ones, so it worked for both adventurous eaters and those who like to keep it simple.

This place is definitely worth a stop if you’re in Cape May. Whether you’re on vacation, out for a date night, or just walking around town, Fine Fellows Creamery is the perfect spot to treat yourself. We’ll definitely be coming...

We visited Cape May for a long weekend trip and came across Fine Fellows near our hotel and saw it on Yelp. We noticed the LGBT flag and it definitely made me want to support the business!

We ordered two scoops in a cup. Delicious salted caramel pretzel scoop and a moose tracks with graham scoop. You can definitely tell the quality of ice cream is of high quality - which accounts for the higher price. I believe our two scoops was $8 which is quite high, however, I will admit the quality was good and the flavors were special. Not an every day treat because of the price but definitely worth a visit if you aren't local!

I also saw that they offered vegan ice cream and milk shakes which is a big plus for my brother who is often left without dessert options. We...