Bagl — Restaurant in Castle Rock

If you’re from the East Coast and miss the taste of a real bagel, look no further than Bagel Cafe in Castle Rock. These bagels are the real deal — perfectly chewy on the inside with that crisp, golden exterior that only a true New York-style bagel delivers. From the first bite, you can tell they know what they’re doing. This isn’t just bread with a hole in it — it’s authentic, flavorful, and made with care.

The variety of cream cheese flavors is incredible. Whether you want classic plain, veggie, scallion, or something a little more adventurous, they’ve got it — and every one I’ve tried has been fresh, creamy, and absolutely delicious. Their sandwiches are fantastic too, piled high with quality ingredients.

On top of that, the service is impressively quick and friendly, even when they’re busy. The staff keeps the line moving without ever making you feel rushed. Bagel Café has become my go-to breakfast spot in Castle Rock. Highly recommend to anyone craving an authentic...

We visited Bagl and were excited for a east coast experience. Overall it was ok and I hope they improve.

The bagels did have that east coast / NYC taste and texture. However, if that's what they are going for the amount of cream cheese was extremely lacking.

When we got the bagels they were not toasted, and we were never even asked when ordering.

Next, the "cross contamination" was a real shame. The onion bagel with herb and garlic cream cheese was fine because it had such a strong flavor. However, the cinnamon bagel with blueberry cream cheese tasted like garlic. Also, there was cheese left behind from where the bagel was cut. This was most likely the result of not cleaning the knife used to cut the breakfast sandwiches.

We would like to visit again, but really hope they update some of...

Jersey boy here. Best bagel I’ve had in a long time. Closest thing you can get to an NY bagel outside of maybe one place in Denver but to me, bagels here are better and so close to home.

Friendly staff and lots of bagels to choose from. The sandwiches were very good as were the variety of schmears offered.

Only thing I would love to see is Taylor Ham for a real NJ pork roll egg and cheese on their everything bagel - which was absolute perfection even with just egg and cheese on it today. Prices were very reasonable as well.

I will be coming back here as often as I possibly can. I wish they were open at 6am so I could get a bagel on my way in to work but I guess I’ll have to go in late when I am craving...