Mystic Lobster Roll Company — Restaurant in Cocoa

Thought about not leaving a review but the world needs to be warned. So... here it goes... My wife and I visit Brevard quite often (my mom is a resident) and my mom likes to take us out when we are here... we decided to invite some other family as well, so she called ahead and made sure there was a reserved table. She had never been to this establishment but read the raving reviews and asked if we wanted to try it... So we show up... looks neat on the outside, live music on the inside, so far so good... we walk in and its about 105° we were greated by our server and seated... aside from us there might've been 8 customers in the restaurant... and an equal amount of staff... as we were waiting to place our order, a guy wearing a restaurant shit sipping on a drink approaches like hes going to take our order.... nope, he just wanted to talk to us... an honest 8-10 minutes goes by before we get our drink order in... in the meantime, as I looked around the restaurant it became abundantly clear that the owner needs to get rid of everyone in that restaurant and hire people that have some pride... the guy who initially approached us didnt complete a single task the entire time we were there and was getting paid(I'm sure) there was one bartender there that appeared to be the manger... she was the only one in the entire restaurant with any motivation to be there... standing next to her was a younger gentleman clean cut. Hair in dreds... For the hour and a half we were there, he stood essentially in one spot talking to a couple around his age... openly hitting a purple vape pen behind the bar in front of customers (you know who you are) disgusting and illegal... So we finally order our food. I got the crab cake sandwich my wife got some hot lobster roll, my mom ordered something similar... one of us ordered the clam chowder and honestly, I would close those restaurant doors and serve the chowder out of a food truck... that was the only positive experience the entire time DELICIOUS!!!... everything else was trash at best... so then we get the bill and for 7 people to eat the bill was around $400... So if you're ever in the mood to have microwaved lobster in a sauna with employees that have little to no desire to be at work (with the exception of our server and the bartender) this might just be the place for you... heard cajon soul, a restaurant up the road was...

Mystic Lobster Rolls , is a delightful culinary experience that seafood lovers won't want to miss. This charming eatery has garnered a loyal following, thanks to its commitment to high-quality ingredients and a laid-back, beachy atmosphere.

Atmosphere: Upon entering Mystic Lobster Rolls, you're greeted by a warm and inviting ambiance that perfectly captures the essence of coastal dining. The decor is simple yet stylish, creating a relaxed vibe that makes it easy to unwind while enjoying your meal. Whether you're dining indoors or on the outdoor patio, the atmosphere is conducive to a leisurely dining experience.

Menu Highlights: The menu at Mystic Lobster Rolls is a seafood lover's paradise, with the lobster rolls being the undeniable star of the show. One of the standout options is the "Mystic" lobster roll, which features generous chunks of tender, fresh lobster dressed in a creamy, flavorful sauce, all piled high on a perfectly toasted, buttery roll. The portion sizes are impressive, ensuring you get your money's worth.

Beyond the lobster rolls, the menu offers a variety of other seafood dishes, including clam chowder, lobster tacos, and seafood salads. Diners have raved about the freshness of the ingredients, with many noting that the lobster tastes like it was just pulled from the ocean.

Service: The service at Mystic Lobster Rolls is often highlighted in reviews as being attentive and friendly. Staff members are knowledgeable about the menu and eager to recommend dishes based on your preferences. Whether you're a seafood aficionado or trying lobster for the first time, the attentive staff will make your dining experience enjoyable.

Value: While some may consider lobster rolls to be on the pricier side, the quality and generous portions at Mystic Lobster Rolls justify the cost. Many customers feel that the experience and taste are worth every penny.

Conclusion: In summary, Mystic Lobster Rolls is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious, fresh seafood. With its inviting atmosphere, exquisite lobster rolls, and excellent service, it's no wonder that this restaurant has become a favorite among locals and tourists alike. Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Mystic Lobster Rolls delivers...

I really wanted to love this place. But after dining there, I decided that I don’t even like it and won’t be returning. First, it took about 15 minutes of driving around before we finally found a parking space, so we had to walk about 3 blocks to get there. Not easy when there’s a disabled person in your party who has difficulty standing/walking, and you have a long street light you have to wait for before crossing a major thoroughfare. Once we arrived, we were barely greeted and were told to sit wherever we wanted. The table we chose was so lopsided that we had to shove stacks of napkins under 3 of the legs to keep the tabletop from moving. We were given menus that were just pieces of paper that were super wrinkled, torn in multiple places, and half soaked in water. They literally looked like they had been fished out of the trash! We ordered lobster rolls and a few drinks. The $12 cocktails were served in small 6oz stemless martini glasses. The Mystic-Tini was a pomegranate vodka drink that was okay, but barely sweet, very watered down and it had no taste of alcohol. The Espresso Martini was only filled about 3/4 of the way, and again I tasted no alcohol. The only thing I tasted was a super sweet, syrupy coffee, with no hint of kahlua. I only had a few small sips. Really gross. Unfortunately, we were extremely disappointed in the lobster rolls too. They were served on open faced hot dog buns, along with some fries, a couple tablespoons of tasty coleslaw and a couple tablespoons of sticky, tasteless baked beans that were super thick and dry. The lobster was chunky, but oh SO DRY and simply tasteless!! It didn’t even look that appetizing. Not even a hint of salt or even the flavor of fresh lobster. We considered sending them back, but didn’t. Then to top things off, when we were finished and ready to leave, we couldn’t get the attention of our server and it took about 15 minutes to finally get the check. We were given a credit card receipt to sign that didn’t have the option to tip, which was weird, so we tipped in cash. From start to finish, there was really nothing positive to say about the whole experience. Total waste of $100.00. Utterly...