Fantastic Fudge — Restaurant in Fernandina Beach

Fantastic Fudge definitely lives up to its name! When I visited, it wasn’t busy at all, which made the experience even more enjoyable. As soon as you walk through the door, you’re greeted with the sweet, irresistible smell of fudge — it instantly pulls you in.The fudge itself is unlike anything I’ve ever had before. It’s rich, creamy, and smooth, almost with the texture of Brie cheese — melt-in-your-mouth perfection. Each bite was decadent without being overly sweet, which made it hard to stop at just one piece.The shop has a charming, nostalgic feel to it, and the staff were welcoming and happy to answer questions. It’s the kind of place that makes you want to bring some home to share (or maybe not share!). If you’re a fudge lover — or even if you think you aren’t — Fantastic Fudge is worth the stop. It’s truly a...

NOT what it claims. I understand why they don’t give out samples: it’s not economical in these tough times and if they did, no one would buy it! I think the ingredients are fresh (at least the marshmallows in the rocky road were), but the fudge was hard the next day! I made the mistake of assuming it looked so good, it would taste at least good. I didn’t get much of a chocolate flavor and certainly not the taste of nuts. My next mistake was buying it shortly before closing on my way to dinner, so I didn’t eat much more than a tiny bit on my way to restaurant…and it wasn’t creamy then. The next day, it was hard, grainy, and crumbly. Perhaps that’s not a popular flavor and it’s been sitting around, but for $10 a slice, I expected more. So...

I’ve lived here for 8 years and LOVED coming to this place. That was until today. I waited for about 8 minutes in front of the ice cream (as usual) and not one of the guys said hello or said anything to me. I waited patiently. I then kindly asked why no one has helped me and I came in before all the other customers. The boy said “because our line wraps around that way”. Again, 8 years and the line was always right in front of the ice cream section if you wanted ice cream.

On top of everything, the boy had NO gloves on while stacking the cones. That’s not sanitary at all. 8 years of loyalty down the drain because these young kids don’t know any manners or how to be courteous and acknowledge a customer...