Amy's Pizza — Restaurant in Indian Shores

recently visited Amy’s Pizza and was thoroughly impressed from start to finish. From the moment I walked in, the atmosphere was inviting — cozy seating, clean space, and the aroma of fresh dough in the air. The staff greeted me with genuine smiles and attentiveness, offering recommendations and making sure everything was just right.

I ordered a classic margherita pizza along with a pepperoni & mushroom combo, and both arrived piping hot, perfectly cooked. The crust had that ideal balance of crisp on the outside and chew on the inside, the sauce tasted homemade and subtly sweet, and the toppings were plentiful and fresh. The margherita’s basil was aromatic and bright; the combo offered generous pepperoni slices and sautéed mushrooms that added great texture.

Beyond the food, I appreciated the sense of care: the server checked in at just the right time, refilled drinks without being intrusive, and made the experience truly comfortable. The pricing felt fair for the quality offered — this isn’t just your standard take-out pie, it feels like you’re dining at a place that values craft.

If you’re looking for a top-notch pizza spot in the Indiana Shores area, Amy’s Pizza is absolutely worth a visit. I’ll definitely be returning and recommending it to friends. Five stars...

Amy’s Pizza is the best pizza around because it’s made with the freshest ingredients and the perfect amount of flavor in every bite. The crust is crispy on the outside but soft and chewy on the inside, just how real pizza should be. The sauce tastes homemade, rich with herbs and tomatoes, and it blends perfectly with the gooey, melted cheese. Every slice feels like it was made with care, not rushed or frozen like most other places.

What makes Amy’s Pizza stand out even more is how it never disappoints—no matter what topping you choose, it’s always cooked just right. The pepperoni is crispy, the vegetables are fresh, and the cheese stretches with every pull. The smell alone makes your mouth water before you even take a bite. Once you do, you can tell why everyone says Amy’s is the best—it’s comfort food...

I am OBSESSED with this place!!! From the moment you walk in, you can feel the love and the family vibe. Amy (the owner) is so kind and welcoming, and the workers make you feel like you're part of their family every time you visit! And the pizza... WOW. The sauce has that amazing homemade flavor, and the cheese melts like a dream. We tried a few different things, and everything blew us away. The garlic knots were soft and buttery, the wings had so much flavor, and even the salad was super fresh!! You can tell they really care about quality and making sure every customer leaves with a smile. This is officially our new favorite spot to grab pizza. Especially being right next to the beach, this is a great...