Lick Ice Cream Indy — Restaurant in Indianapolis

I really wanted to try this ice cream spot. Being it’s my first time in Indiana. I’ve heard so many great reviews about the “Garage”. My partner I asked to sample one of the ice creams “munchies”. We were rudely told, we were only to sample ice cream if we purchased. Of course we would have if we knew what it tasted like “right” “like what does Munchies taste like”My partner and I love new ice cream shops and never have witness this before. Now, was it because we were a lesbian couple or black! I hope either one. Just know it’s unsettling feeling to be treated like this in 2024. We are so confused by this statement.. That comment lost multiple customers as we were a group of 20 people looking for dessert. You never know who you’re serving!!! Remember to treats customers...

Ice cream is mostly unusual flavors. Flavors include sweet corn, Old Fashioned. And, actually, the "novelty" flavors, to me, taste better than their versions of more standard flavors. Also significantly sweeter than most ice creams, with slightly below average creaminess.

Again - in coming to the Garage food hall, prices are higher than you'd expect elsewhere, parking will add significantly to your food bill, the cash register will attempt to strong-arm a tip (color me skeptical that it reaches the nonowner performing the task of scooping ice cream into a dish) and you can get ice cream that's as good or better within walking distance... These factors make this a tough sell for anyone but a...

Hard to find but worth looking. There were 4 fun flavors in the case but they had pints and 1/2 pints of many flavors. My kids enjoyed kid sized scoops (which as a parent I appreciate a place that has a smaller size) of cranberry shortbread. They both gobbled it up even if it was a bit tart. I had the gingersnaps lemon curd which was fantastic and my kids ate half of (not cool!). My mother had the s'mores which was delicious! The ice cream itself isn't super creamy, but the flavor makes up for it. The price is reasonable for what you get. The owner was there and interacted with my kids (her 4 yo son stopped in for a short bit too) and she was very informative....