Wicked Lick Ice Cream Key West — Restaurant in Key West

10/16/2020: Not worth the cost AT ALL. Extremely over priced and not good.

10/17/2020: owner responded that this rating was a former disgruntled employee that was let go. I am absolutely not a former employee and am shocked at the owner’s lack of concern for a negative experience at their business. My husband and I have walked past Wicked Lick several times while in Key West and finally decided to try it out last night. We were offered samples which was nice and the samples were good. We both ordered the peanut butter in a waffle cone, mine with sprinkles and his with what he thought would be brownie bites. I’m not sure if overall the flavor wasn’t good past the initial sample or if the server (as it was not the same person to take our order) was mistaken and gave us the wrong order as it tastes like plain vanilla. My husband also only received what I would describe as one miniature brownie plopped on top.. not what he was expecting for “brownie bites”. Aside from paying nearly $20 for what tasted like plain vanilla ice cream, it was half melted by the time the server handed it to us and quite difficult to even eat since it was essentially liquid in a cone. Not satisfied at all, disturbed the owner would immediately blame a past employee for a bad review, and will not...

Wicked Lick came onto my radar during my first trip to Key West after doing some research and walking temptingly past it several times right along Duval Street. But sadly, we didn’t ever stop to further investigate. So when we came back a few months later it was an easy choice.

The lady working made the entire experience. I didn’t see what her name was but she was sweeter than the ice cream, and she even gave us coupons!

I got the peanut butter ice cream and it was literally like eating frozen peanut butter- which is totally a good thing! Their menu seemed really fun too- the entire place is pirate themed, and they call the toppings to the ice cream a “booty” and other small fun touches.

Overall a fun little place and a good stop along the walk to shops and the other end...

Probably the worst ice-cream we've ever had. We saw the lady making it from through the window, and she we using liquid nitrogen, so we thought it was going to be amazing. Ordered the blueberry and the caramel butter cookie flavours and they were both flavourless and worst of all, icy.

For $8, it was a complete con!

I explained to the lady that our ice cream was icy. She smiled and said yes. When I said it wasn't supposed to be like that she said that it was supposed to be icy. That really got us angry, so we demanded our money back, and she just smiled again.

I said it again, and then she said she would contact the manager. A few mins later she gave our money back.

We chucked the ice cream in the bin on our way out.

Don't pretend that ice cream is supposed to be...