Slice of NY Pizza — Restaurant in Knightdale

Where do I start? Well to begin, I am native of NJ/NY so I can tell you right away that this place is severely overpriced. Tried them out for the first time and do not think I would return until they lowered their prices, or gave you larger quantities for what they charge. To actually call your business Slice of NY you must first understand that in New York when you get a slice of pizza it’s a very generous slice for about half the price. In NJ, the Strombolis are about twice the size for the same price of $10.99. New Yorkers also prefer much larger cups of marinara, And believe me, we really like our sauce. You charge $4.99 for extremely small desserts. Literally a thin sliver of cake, which is completely ridiculous. Please keep in mind there are a lot of us folks moving down from New Jersey and New York and we will definitely know where to spot the good pizza joints from the bad. I will have to pass on this place next time, was not impressed. Food tasted just ok, but have a feeling you may only be doing business with the locals going forward. Restaurant smelled like Pinesol. I know a guy from NY that brought his pizza business down to Florida, who is doing it the right way with prices that are not inflated & generous portions. He is literally making a killing and opened up two...

Slice of NY Pizza lives up to its name, serving up generous slices of pizza alongside a diverse menu that includes cheeseburgers, gyros, lasagna, salads, and more Italian favorites. Many dishes are made fresh and from scratch, adding a layer of authenticity to the dining experience. The standout, of course, is the pizza. Expect large, foldable slices bursting with flavor. While the service might have a relaxed New York City feel, it's worth noting that it can be a bit slower than some may prefer.

What we loved: Massive pizza slices: The generous portions are a true highlight, satisfying even the heartiest appetites. Freshly prepared dishes: The commitment to using fresh ingredients shines through in the quality of the food. Variety on the menu: With options ranging from pizza to pasta and beyond, there's something to please every palate.

Areas for improvement: Service speed: Service can sometimes be slow, which may not suit everyone's schedule. Price point: Prices can be a bit higher than average for some menu items.

Overall: Slice of NY Pizza offers a taste of the Big Apple with its large, flavorful pizza slices and a menu brimming with options, the quality of the food and the generous portions make it a...

I am very unsure as to why this pizza place has any kind of bad reviews. The service inside was outstanding. They had almost every table with someone at it, and i was still talked to within seconds of walking in the door. The kind woman behind the counter was very efficient about getting my order and i was out of the building with my food within 2 minutes. The slice of white pizza i got is superb. After the first bite it reminded me of back home. Bursting with garlic ricotta flavor, it is one of the best pieces of pizza I have had since moving down south. However, the stromboli was something else. It was absolutely without a doubt BETTER than the ones I used to get growing up. Exploding with a perfect balance of pepperoni and sausage, wrapped perfectly in a flavorful crust. If i could give this business more than 5 stars I would. Just gained a life time customer. And to address the bad reviews, maybe people need to realize a business can get busy and it has an off day or two. To stop giving years worth of business over 1 bad...