Upper Crust Pizza Marathon — Restaurant in Marathon

If you’re in Marathon, FL and craving pizza, do yourself a favor and check out this hidden gem of a pizzeria! We stopped in during our trip to the Keys, and it honestly exceeded all our expectations.

From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a warm smile and welcoming energy from the staff. Everyone was super friendly, accommodating, and genuinely seemed happy to be there—which really set the tone for the experience. We placed our order right when we arrived and were pleasantly surprised that everything was ready in just about 20 minutes. Quick, efficient, and piping hot!

Now let’s talk about the pizza. It was exactly the kind of thin-crust pizza you hope to find—crispy on the bottom with just the right amount of chew, perfectly baked, and loaded with flavor. You can tell they take pride in their ingredients and preparation. Every bite was delicious, and we found ourselves reaching for another slice even after we were full.

We also ordered the cheesy garlic bread, and wow—it was a standout. Gooey, buttery, and packed with garlicky goodness. It was the perfect appetizer and great for sharing with the family.

The atmosphere was casual, clean, and very family-friendly. Whether you’re dining in with kids or meeting up with friends, it’s a great spot to relax and enjoy a good meal without any fuss. The layout and vibe made it easy to feel right at home.

The only downside—and it’s a small one—is that dogs aren’t allowed inside. As a dog-loving family, we always appreciate when spots are a little more pet-friendly, especially in the Keys. That said, it wouldn’t stop us from coming back. We just know next time to plan accordingly.

All in all, this is a must-visit stop for anyone passing through Marathon. Great food, even better service, and an atmosphere that makes you feel like a local. We’ll definitely be back on...

Restaurant gave me another person's order and the owner/manager ended up yelling at me over the phone when I called. I walked in and placed an order right after they opened. I gave them my name and came back 30 minutes later to pick it up and was handed two large pizza boxes. I had ordered one large pizza and garlic cheese bread. When I got back to our rental house, I opened to the boxes to see that there were two pizzas with toppings that my family would not eat. When I called the restaurant to let them know, I found out that there was a mix-up and my order was given to someone else. I wanted my order remade and I was going to come pick it up. I had spent over $40 and now had food that my family would not eat. I was put on the phone with the manager who told me that he would not remake it and that I received two pizzas for the price of one. He said that he had already lost money and he told the other woman he wasn't remaking anything. He refused to give me a refund or remake my food. When I asked him for a solution he proceeded to yell at me telling me it was my fault and that I should have checked the order before I left the restaurant. My husband grabbed the phone and then the owner/manager hung up on him. We attempted to call back and have a conversation with him but he apparently "left the store". I was left dumbfounded at his lack of professionalism and the way he speaks to his customers, or any personal in general for that matter! I spent $40 and still had to come up with dinner for my kids. I had a bite of the pizza and it tasted like a Chef Boyardee mix. Waste of money! No idea how this guy has a business! Truly wish I could give this...

I had a feeling for spagetti and meatballs, i ordered wings because i tried them before and i said i want the spagetti and meat ball dinner 17$ she said u want the bolognese suace...i said what is that? She explained it was meat sause...i explained i want spagetti and meatballs. The waitress got my order wrong and even explained she doesnt work upront when i asked whats my total...so she said 31.16 when i get there they only accept cash so i brought in my 33$..she then said my total is 33.33$ i said no u said 31.16$ when i called back to say my order is wrong the owner got on the phone...(a woman) said no the waitress said you order meat sauce. I said no i order meatballs...i offered to bring the spagetti and meat sauce back because i dont want meat sauce and to get my meatballs they said no...they cannot through it away and that i needed to pay for a spagetti and meat ball...i said i already paid for a spagetti and meatball and got meat sauce...im pissed off because i wanted meatballs....dont go there the owners are not nice and will not give u your right order! I would not have wrote a review if i think for a moment i ordered meat sauce....im pissed and i will never go there and i will never recommend it to anybody. This place sucks! A 17$ goes down the drain simply because somebody messed up my order and i have to get something else to eat because i dont want meat sauce. Another owner even got on the phone and told me (a man this time) he believes his waitress and she didnt mess up my order and he was extremely busy and that the phone call would go no where then hung up! How rude! To bad for my 17$ and to bad for my feeling...