Crusty's Pizza — Restaurant in McCall

Crusty's Pizza has completely exceeded my expectations and has become our go-to spot in McCall. Brian, the owner, has created something truly special here – a neighborhood eatery that perfectly captures the mountain town vibe while delivering exceptional food and atmosphere. The homemade sourdough pizzas are absolutely incredible. The Big Crusty and 4-Pigs are my personal favorites, but I have to give special mention to the WildWest pizza with elk sausage – it's truly out of this world and you won't find anything like it elsewhere. The sourdough crust has the perfect balance of crispy exterior and chewy interior that only comes from authentic, carefully crafted dough. What really sets Crusty's apart is their expansion into BBQ offerings, and wow, are they knocking it out of the park! The wings are perfectly smoked and sauced and their homemade southern coleslaw is the perfect complement. It's clear they've put the same attention to detail into their BBQ as they have with their pizzas. The atmosphere is fantastic – the outdoor patio is cozy and inviting, especially around the fire pit on those cool mountain evenings. Their selection of beer and wine perfectly complements the food, and the live bands on Sundays and Wednesdays add such a great community feel to the place. Brian has truly established a top-notch eatery that welcomes everyone. Whether you're a local or just visiting McCall, Crusty's is an...

Killer thin crust pizza! Super fun, low key, local vibe, all are welcome. What makes the pizza so good? Top notch ancient sourdough starter that is tended and fed like it is their child. Next, great quality ingredients, toppers, sauce and cheese. Great salads too. Lastly a worker first mentality. Staff are paid fairly, before tips, and treated kindly. Work hard and treat the customer well and they are supported by ownership. That's how pizza is made to taste this good. If you are expecting dominos pricing, turn around now! You cannot pull off the above description in a small and seasonal mountain resort town without paying a premium. You won't be disappointed if you keep an open mind. Currently slow smoked chicken wings (seriously tasty), and delivery (with a delivery fee) are available! To wrap it up, Crusty's Pizza has been staunchly dedicated to FREE live music since the day they opened their doors, and has been McCall's longest standing traveling circuit live music venue. Music nights are a blast, but if you are looking for a quiet, low key affair be warned, someone may be dancing...

We walked out of our truck and immediately where just absolutely drawn to the smokey sweet smell of peppers being skillfully smoked for the house made habenaro honey... but was quickly embraced by the absolute quaint atmosphere of this pizza place... the owner Brain was ever so gracious to come to our table and tell me the story of the place and about their menu and their pursuit to continue to stick to the tradition of the original owner to source good local ingredients to keep a wide selection of also local beers and very choice wines.... they do live music every Friday during the winter as well as a fire crackling in the hearth. They recommended their signature pie and it (the SmokeJumper) didn't disappoint it paired with a Big Crusty and a couple of local draft beers was an absolute must if you find yourself in or near McCall Idaho...the absolute best pizza in south western...