Lola & Giuseppe's Bakery — Restaurant in Mifflin Township

Really wanted to like this place. We prefer supporting mom and pop/local business however, however, I cannot recommend their whole cassata cake. Can't speak to anything else here, so hopefully other items are great and you won't have my experience. My husband ordered a cassata cake for my birthday (I am from Cleveland where there is a large Italian influence, however harder to find cassata cakes in Columbus), and it truly was the worst cassata cake I have ever had. Dry, dense, not authentic. Supposed to be strawberries and had random cherries. Had to literally use 2 hands to push the knife through, that's how dense and dry it was. Close to no filling. Would not recommend buying their cassata cake, specifically. Not sure what we will be doing with the rest of this cake, as I will not waste my calories on something that is not enjoyable. If you are in the market, ive had a pretty good one from a bakery off high street in short north. Lola and guiseppes seems to have good reviews, so I'm sure they have items that are tastier... Just...

This was my second time coming here and it did not disappoint. It’s a bakery spin off of the restaurant next door, Lola and Giuseppe Trattoria. Which is also great and I will do a review of them later. The Chocolate Chip Cheesecake was so creamy, rich, dense, velvety and smooth. It wasn’t overly tangy which is how I like my cheesecake. The cannoli was also amazing. Crispy and crunchy on the outside but so creamy and rich on the inside. Both tasted so fresh and so delicious. Also the two girls working there were so nice and friendly. I can’t wait to comeback and try their cassata cake and...

We have stopped here numerous times, and when we had a taste of the pumpkin spice and apple pie bars, we immediately put an order in for Thanksgiving! The bars are huge so I sliced them, ya know so they last longer and I will have more for myself later, 😆 Just need them to open up in Pataskala one day so they can get half my paycheck.. maybe that would not be good.. 🤔 Thanks for the fresh goodies and kind words even when y'all were super busy! The cookies and cannolis are pretty good too!...