Abitino's Pizza — Restaurant in New York

I’ve eaten at countless pizza places in NYC, but Abitinos absolutely blew me away. The moment you walk in, you’re hit with that heavenly smell of freshly baked dough, bubbling cheese, and rich tomato sauce — it’s the kind of aroma that instantly makes you hungry.

The place has that classic New York vibe — simple, authentic, a little busy, but full of character. The staff were genuinely friendly and welcoming. Before I even sat down properly, they had already handed me a drink and recommended their top pizzas of the day.

I ordered a classic Margherita and a slice of Pepperoni, and honestly, it was a revelation. The crust was perfectly crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. The sauce tasted like real, sun-ripened tomatoes — slightly sweet, well-seasoned, and full of flavor. The cheese was fresh, creamy, and stretched beautifully with every bite. You can tell they use top-quality ingredients — nothing processed, nothing fake, just pure craftsmanship and love for good pizza.

What really stood out to me was how the owner came by to check if everything was okay. That personal touch makes such a difference — it didn’t feel like I was just another customer, but like I was a guest in someone’s kitchen.

The prices are also surprisingly fair, especially for New York. You get real quality at a great value, which is rare in this city.

I was so impressed that I grabbed a few slices to go, and even cold the next morning they were still amazing — that’s when you know a pizza is truly great.

Bottom line: If you’re in NYC and looking for the perfect pizza, go to Abitinos. It’s not one of those overhyped tourist traps — it’s the real deal. You can taste the passion, the tradition, and the pride in every bite. I’m definitely coming back —...

If you're in the mood for a slice that tastes like cardboard seasoned with disappointment, look no further than Abitinos Pizza in Manhattan. I had the unfortunate experience of subjecting my taste buds to their so-called "pizza," and let me tell you, it was a culinary catastrophe of epic proportions. First off, let's talk about flavor—or rather, the complete lack thereof. I've had more taste sensations from licking postage stamps. The crust was as flavorless as a piece of stale bread left out in the sun too long, and don't even get me started on the excuse for tomato sauce they dared to smear on top. But wait, it gets worse. The cheese, if you could even call it that, resembled a sad attempt at melted plastic. It had all the gooey texture of rubber cement and none of the cheesy goodness you'd expect from a decent slice. Let's not forget the desperate scavenger hunt for condiments. Every poor soul in that pitiful excuse for an eatery was desperately rummaging through the sad selection of condiments, hoping to salvage some semblance of flavor from their tasteless cardboard discs. In conclusion, if you have any respect for your taste buds, your stomach, and your sanity, steer clear of Abitinos Pizza. It's a culinary wasteland where flavor goes to die and dreams of a decent meal are crushed into a sad, flavorless oblivion. Save yourself the agony and go elsewhere for your pizza fix. Your taste buds...

On August 19th around 9:40 PM, I left my wallet next to the register while buying a slice. A few minutes later I called the store, but I was yelled at that it wasn’t there and was asked not to call back. Later that night, my wallet’s AirTag still showed it at the store until 11pm, past closing time, and the next morning the AirTag was disabled.

I reached out again the following day to ask if the cameras could be checked, but was told the owner was unavailable and haven’t received a reply to my email either. Unfortunately, this left me without answers and I’ve since had to involve my bank and file a report.

This was a very disappointing and stressful experience.

Edit:

First of all you are already lying because I did in fact send you an email 3 days ago, check the picture I posted.

Your response shows how disrespectful you are to your customers. Just read your other 1 star reviews, and quite frankly your 5 stars are pretty questionable.

I have emailed you and gave you a few days to respond before leaving this review.

The fact that you will only respond to me after leaving a review, and flat out lie to save face is disgusting.

Let's clear this up once and for all, check your footage, and email me proof that they did not take it. And don't tell me that your footage magically disappeared.

I am certain that they took it, but if you prove me wrong I will...