Baby Blues Luncheonette — Restaurant in New York

Baby Blues Luncheonette definitely lives up to the hype. When we arrived, it was already pretty crowded, and for good reason. They don’t take reservations, so be prepared to wait especially on a Sunday around 11:30 a.m. like we did. We ended up waiting about two hours, but they do send you a notification when your table’s ready, and they also show you how many parties are ahead of you, which makes the wait feel a bit more manageable.

The place itself is small, and tables are pretty close together, but it wasn’t an issue for us. The menu is straightforward and easy to navigate, and the prices are very reasonable. My partner got the “Plato’s Plate,” and I went for the “Chicken Club.” Both were fantastic. My partner gave her dish a 9/10, and I’d give mine the same rating. The price-to-quality ratio was excellent, and we had no complaints. The only small note from my partner was that the bacon on her plate was a bit greasy, but it wasn’t a big deal.

We also shared a side of “Greek Potatoes and Tzatziki.” That dish was another 9/10. The only downside was that there wasn’t quite enough tzatziki for all the potatoes, so I’d recommend asking for extra on the side if you order it. No real issue though, just a small suggestion. We had an “Iced Coffee” and a “Regular Coffee” with our meal, and both were spot on.

One more thing: we were treated to a complimentary dish of fresh strawberries and blueberries with whipped cream (as you can see in the photo I included). We’re not sure what it was called, but it was light, refreshing, and delicious. Easily a 10/10, and I’d highly recommend it if you get the chance.

The service was also excellent. Our server was friendly and attentive, and even the hostess deserves a shoutout. We arrived a bit late for our seating time, but she was understanding and still got us a table despite it being so busy. Really appreciated that.

The bill was pretty reasonable for everything we got, and I left a $15 tip because of the great service and the complimentary fruit bowl.

Overall, we had a fantastic experience, great food, great atmosphere, and excellent service. The wait time can be long (ours was 2 hours), but it’s totally worth it when you consider the quality of the food and the prices. I’ll definitely be back, and I highly recommend you give it a try too!

Thanks for reading, and I...

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Baby Blues Luncheonette – A True Williamsburg Gem

One of the best brunch experiences we’ve had in NYC. Baby Blues Luncheonette has that rare mix of charm, flavor, and personality that makes it feel like an instant classic.

The atmosphere is vintage, cozy, and full of character—think hanging plants, old-school decor, and art that brings the space to life. It’s casual but cool, and the vibe is welcoming from the second you walk in.

We ordered: • Baklava Banana Pancakes – unbelievably good, warm and gooey with just the right balance of flavors • Halloumi Platter – fresh, light, and perfectly Mediterranean • Goat + Fig Sandwich – sweet and savory in the best way • Scrambled Eggs & Sides – simple dishes done really well

Every bite was packed with flavor. We didn’t even stop to take photos—just ate everything immediately, which says it all.

Service was also fantastic. Lily took care of us and made the whole experience even better with her warmth and attentiveness.

Fast service, amazing food, and a vibe that makes you want to hang out all day. Whether you’re a local or just visiting Williamsburg, this spot is a must. We’ll...

I was excited to try this place since it’s all over social media, but was disappointed by many parts of the experience. My friend and I dined on Monday afternoon. We put our names down and waited 30 minutes. When we were seated and ready to order we were notified that they were out of smoked salmon, potatoes and bacon… and the one thing I wanted was the smoked salmon feta toast. I ordered the halloumi sandwich and paid extra to get a runny egg and avocado on the sandwich. Instead of avocado, it arrived with bacon (which they were allegedly out of… and that I did not want) and a fully hard, fried egg. Also, I wanted to share a sweet breakfast item with my friend. We didn’t see pancakes on the menu so got a sweet toast instead. Then, we saw people eating beautiful pancakes near us.. which turned out to be an “off menu” item that no one cared to mention to us when ordering. The ingredients tasted fresh, but I did not get to eat any of the food that I wanted and the service was very cold...