Bagel Story — Restaurant in New York

I don’t think this place is for me , but it might be for others who are looking for fresh pastry.

I have ordered twice from this location.On my first visit, I ordered a toasted bagel with cream cheese. I was disappointed. The bagel was barely toasted and had a mountain of cream cheese. The bagel itself was great. If you are ordering bagels for a staff event, this is a great location. The bagels are made on the spot.

I decided to give this place a try again. I bought a toasted bagel with butter and a nondairy latte. My tummy hurled after eating this combo. The bagel was swimming in oil from too much butter and the latte taste like Caramel coffee syrup.

I don’t think this place is for me , but it might be for others who are looking for fresh pastry.

I’m a very picky person and I tend to prepare my food myself because it’s so hard to find a location that prepare things the way I like it.

On my next trip to this location, I would purchase...

UPDATED REVIEW!

~So, unfortunately I must update this review. I went from giving Bagel Story my business two times a week to no longer going there at all. My last two experiences were negative. They refuse to put salt, pepper, ketchup, and hot sauce on my egg and cheese even despite the fact that they used to do it every time when they first opened. I think it’s bullsh*t and sheer laziness. The employees here have the worst attitudes ever. It’s unacceptable....It’s NY. It’s not uncommon to want SPKH on your sandwich. I went here yesterday, hoping they’d actually listen and make my pricey food correctly. Well, they didn’t. They didn’t even put salt or pepper on it!!! The eggs were so bland and tasteless even with dipping it into a tiny little ketchup container they gave me. I was NOT happy and I will no longer be wasting my money here. Go to Wholesome Foods on Atlantic instead. They aren’t lazy and have no issues cooking your food the way...

First I like to say I had high hopes for this place the decor and ambiance of the place is lovely. With that being said I am highly disappointed. Firstly it is way over priced,secondly I ordered my food to stay but it was served in to go containers .I ordered a grilled chicken and it was bland unseasoned and a mess,it came with approximately 10 individual chips for $10. My husband ordered a pastrami 1888 and he is pleased with it but his came with less chips then mines did. He also ordered a blues clues smoothie it doesn’t say that it comes with milk on the menu but there is milk in it. The man who took my order I think could have been new he didn’t seem to know the pos system well. Overall this place could be better. P.S I thought the chips were freshly made but I think they...