Jamaica Fish Market — Restaurant in New York

3rd Visit (March 2022) So they have hot sauce and they have ketchup. Both are red sauces in plastic bottles. The hot sauce is ready then the ketchup but I've managed to grab the hot sauce two out of my three visits thinking it was ketchup. All I can say about the hot sauce is that it's hot. I've suggested that they label these bottles, hot sauce and ketchup so that big dumb people like me don't make this mistake. Anyway, once again absolutely delicious and a lot of bang for your buck. They do a wonderful job and have wonderful food. Not the place to wear a jacket and tie or for big sit-down fancy dinner. Just good food and plenty of it.

2nd Visit (December 2021): Location is about a mile from our coop, so it's a nice walk/exercise. I had their "Cheap" Fish Sandwich ($5.50), with Fires ($7.00), wife had Salmon ($14.00). Very generous portions! Interesting that every one who was their when we arrivedm or came in when we were already eating ordered Soup. Definitely have to have some next visit.

1st Visit (September 2021): Hidden, Secret treasure. Fresh, Fresh, Fresh (did I say Fresh?) Seafood. Not very fancy setting. Not really any parking (hint: park at Starbucks lot). But great food, great prices. Oh and they have fresh seafood, live lobsters,...

My favorite go to fish spot. This location has been around for many years. I used to just get fish here for Good Friday until i had their Salmon Filler and wooooooo. Best salmon ever. For all of 2019-current I’ve had fish about 2 times a week from here. Amazing and unique taste and flavoring used. I love the blend of Chinese options and other sides such as maduros and tostones (green and sweet plantains) my go to is tostones, fried rice and salmon filet. The owner (woman) is amazing. She makes it her business to get to know you and make sure any issue is resolved. Out of the full consistent year that Ive come here I only had 1 situation where the fish tasted a bit old. She made sure to give me a new fish and asked if she could give us anything else since our other food was cold. Very nice staff. There is another woman there that helps out and she is very attentive and fast to prepare orders. I would highly recommend if you’re in the area to get your fish from here. Awesome. Never long wait times or...

Absolutely terrible experience. I got the wrong order and also the customer service from the staff is the worst I have ever seen. While waiting for my food another customer was denied her food because the staff made a mistake with her order then asked her to pay extra for their mistake. The customer refused to pay and the staff refused to give her the food, he actually opened her bag and took out some of the fried plantains to accommodate for the $2. I was just sitting there in utter disbelief. For two dollars they had the audacity to open this ladies food and take out some, while asking her to pay for it. This will be my last time ever coming here and also I will be telling everyone I know not to come...