Penny Jo's — Restaurant in New York

• June 29th 2025 back again and still lovely

So already went back for Father’s Day and yes I enjoy this place will definitely be here a lot

Pro tip ask for Valerie,

although everyone will help you and assist in your service experience and everyone is amazing she recommended an amazing drink for me. She recommended the sazerac!!! Never heard of this before but it was nothing short of spectacular.

I truly enjoyed my experience here from the staff the customers to the food to the vibe to the music to the energy in the room. This place checks all the spots a small local hidden gem 💎 I hope it blows up but doesn’t at the same time. The decor was great when u see wu tang signs you know you in the right place.

Another pro tip get the meat and cheese board you will not be disappointed I promise this was hands one of the best I’ve had and I’ve had a lot 😂 I was truly impressed. I’ll be definitely making this place a spot I visit often I will be here atleast once a month. I will continue to update with what to eat and what to order and drink.

Another pro tip never say I didn’t put you on.

They have Brugal 1888 it’s one of the best rums you will ever have trust me!!!!

I hope you enjoyed this review if you come please tell me what you think and what you had.

Like always thanks for the support the likes and follows I truly appreciate it.

Also follow me on IG @imbroke_eats and...

On Wednesday May 9, 2019 I walked into this bar. I live down the street and I just wanted to grab some food and a drink. As soon as I sat down the bartender said that he couldn’t server me and I needed to leave his establishment. A few minutes later the owner of the place grabs my shirt and says that I need to leave. In his own words he said that he didn’t server my kind of people. I have been living in the heights for years and my grandmother raised her children in the heights. I will not be giving my money to this establishment. It breaks my heart that a business like this are not here for our community but just here to take our dollars. Spend your money on establishments that help build the heights and who are mindful of the people...

I stopped by for a drink and something light to eat. I had a bourbon neat & meat & cheese platter. It was just what I wanted. Great selection of meats & cheeses. Two choices for breads ( loved the warm mini-baguette) & some dipping sauces plus olives & pickles. Really the right combination of savory & sweet. Joseph the bartender & the person who prepared the food ( sorry I should have gotten his name) were both attentive & professional. Just what you want in neighborhood bar. I'm sorry I'll be missing the jazz music tonight!! I would definitely recommend this to other. The selection of drinks are many, they are gradually expanding their food menu & the service us great!! All in all it was a very pleasant...