The Crazy Mason Milkshake Bar Fort Mill — Restaurant in Tega Cay

Went with my family of 4, here's the scoop.

HUGE menu. Think Cheesecake Factory size menu but for desserts. You'll want to have an idea of what flavor you want. Do you want a fruit flavor? Chocolate? Peanut butter? That will help narrow it down.

We spent $35.70 on 2 desserts, plastic cups. For a few extra bucks you can get your dessert in a mason jar and keep the jar.

Desserts have creative names, loads of toppings. Holy cow is the whip cream thick. It was literally 2-3 inches of whip cream in the dessert. Whip cream so thick, you could scoop it on your spoon, invert it, and it won't move. Seemed excessive.

Toppings, ice cream portion, pretty standard. This place is very reminiscent of 90's dessert bar if you've been there. Generally unremarkable. It's an ice cream sundae / milkshake in a cup.

They have a Fort Mill themed dessert with peaches. When I asked where those peaches come from (for a cobbler) - they come from a can. We have some of the best peaches down the road from here. Sad to hear there wasn't some sort of partnership with Peach Stand for a legitimate SC peach.

The ice cream scene is pretty competitive in FM, in my opinion. Springs Farm, Whits, Abbotts, Bruesters, DQ (not real ice cream but OK)...this was definitely the most pricey. Might be a place to splurge. Fun and crazy for the kids.

Probably not a regular...

Came here with a group 6 adults and 2 kids, they were very fast and had plenty of space for us. They don’t have a changing station in their bathroom so I had to walk back to my car to change my baby. It wasn’t a big deal for me but I wanted to include that for any families with small children. I was a little hesitant about getting a crazy jar because of the mess but they make it easy by supplying plates and big cups to take your jar home.

The ice cream was delicious and the space was decorated very nicely. It’s a perfect spot for a date especially if you’re not big on sweets. One jar is perfect to split with another person. Not so great for families with a lot of kids, only because the bill gets expensive fast.

For two people it was a little over $30, which is more on the pricier side but you kind of get two desserts in one. I ate the ice cream while there and took my whole brownie home for later. It was a very...

This is one of the best locations I’ve been to!! The staff was incredibly friendly, helpful, and extremely patient while I looked over the menu (because let’s be honest, there’s a lot and everything looks so good😅), and they made the whole process easy and fast, even with a decent crowd.

I ended up ordering the Sweet Cheesus, and it was unreal. A rich strawberry cheesecake milkshake topped with a slice of actual cheesecake, fresh strawberries, whipped cream, and a strawberry drizzle—served in a keepsake Fort Mill mason jar rimmed with frosting and graham cracker crumbs. It looked insane and tasted just as good. Definitely sweet, but not in a way that was too much. It somehow balanced rich, creamy, fruity, and crunchy all in one.

This isn’t your average dessert stop—it’s more of an experience. Perfect for celebrations, social media pics, or just treating yourself after a long week. I will definitely be going back...