Cheesy Eddie's — Restaurant in Town of Henrietta

Absolutely a Rochester dessert staple and a rich reminder of how lucky we are to enjoy regional specialty products.

My partner loves the cheese cake slices and I am a huge fan of the sandwich cookies.

I would love ya even more if you would do seasonal flavors of the cookies beyond oatmeal, CC, and PB. Maybe lemon sugar or blueberry oatmeal for spring?

Also BEGGING you to bring back the mandarin orange flavor I stupidly never ordered from your South Ave location years ago. I'm not a key lime girly, but I LOVE citrus.

Lmk if you ever need someone to try any prospective items and...

This was my first time at Cheesy Eddie’s (I’m from out of town). We ordered 5 cheesecakes for our wedding. The cheesecake was a hit and everyone loved it, it’s perfectly creamy with the perfect amount of crust.

Pick up was a breeze, they had everything ready on time and even helped me out to my car. Highly recommend!! Not only are their cheesecakes delicious, their employees are amazing. So nice and so inviting, you can tell they love their jobs! Working with the wedding coordinator, Lindsy, was a breeze too!

The only downfall is I live 5 hours away or I would try everything...

First of all, the cheese cake they have in the picture for $16.50 is for 1-2 people granted you will have it for a couple days. Or it’s for a child on it’s birthday to dig into. It’s 2 inches around. Maybe 3. It’s tiny. We thought it was a joke when my husband brought it home. The carrot cake a tiny one is $16 also. That feeds about 4 people. And it’s gross it tasted awful. It’s the worst carrot cake I ever had. Jackson’s bakery puts this place to shame. Save your money no offense but price gauging at its...