New York Panini — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

Giving an update because it looks like they’ve found their footing again. I’m happy to say I gave them another chance and they’re back to good food and great service. There are some salads I miss, but being able to build my own helps. I think they’re the best in town for salads and panini. I also love their Cajun fries. Their delivery is usually very fast and the drivers are friendly. I’m pretty confident my original review is outdated:

I’m sorry to say this used to be my go to for salads, but the last 3 times I ordered my salad wasn’t made correctly. The third time, they didn’t include salad dressing. I called and was told they were out of honey mustard, so instead of calling to let me know, they didn’t change charge me for the dressing, they just sent a dry salad. Why not call to offer an alternative? They get your phone number when you order, but don’t have time to use it? I ended up going to Stop and Shop (which is in walking distance of the restaurant, so if they cared to not run out of dressing, they have options in a pinch) and getting my own dressing. I think they’ve changed ownership/management because they used to care and I used to order from them a few times a month. No more caring, no...

4 people, 4 Paninis, no complaints… well almost. Service was great and the people were nice. The food is stellar. Been looking for a good panini place for a while and they mostly fall short. These are fully loaded, to a point that each sandwich is quite heavy. In fact, only one person was able to finish. Next, the sandwich is compressed and the bread it toasted to crunchy perfection. Everyone loved their sandwich. Parking lot is also near by and they have the Christmas set up right outside. Now for our only complaint… the seating. It’s uncomfortable and our group of 4 had no where to sit together. They have small barrels with 2 uncomfy stools at each. Maybe it’s not meant to be an eat in place, but if that’s what you’re looking for, don’t plan to sit comfortably and with more than 2 people. Considering how good these sandwiches are, and how it’s worth a trip to go there, I hope they update...

The food was expensive 48 dollars for 2 paninis and fries and its a takeout joint not even a sitdown restaurant with waiters....the wait was long even though we were the only 2 people there. The portions are large and the fillings inside the paninis were great we got the Philly panini and the Buffalo Mac n cheese panini.... but the bread was extremely soggy from the fillings the outside of the bread is very crispy but the inside got incredibly soggy... also very greasy I only ate about a quarter of my panini because I could tell it was a billion calories. We also got Tuscan fries.... I dont know what Tuscan fries means they were just regular fries they were very crispy but dissapointingly they had absolutely no salt at all. I'm on a mission to try all the restaurants in Huntington but sadly would most likely never...