Marcello's Pizza — Restaurant in York

My kid wanted a Marcello's stromboli and being a YCP student had obviously visited the shop plenty times before and enjoys the food. We decided to give it a go since it would provide food options the family could agree on. It's an interesting place for sure. Interior is decent so we decided to eat there. We take a look at the menu presented above the pizza display and it's anyone's guess how much each item costs. Not a good start. There are no prices listed anywhere until we head to the register where a paper menu is open. Ok, not bad, prices are reasonable. Looking up there's a plexiglass screen between the customer and cashier. A little off putting but I get it. It's in York City, I'm sure they've seen and had crazy things happen in the shop. I place the food order and try to also purchase a 2 liter since the individual drink prices are close to $4 for a regular size. Immediately, the cashier barks out that bottled drinks and 2 liters are for take out orders only. Minus 1 ⭐. The only option is the fountain. Fine. We get cups for the fountain, turn around to fill them, and see a letter sized note indicating 1 refill per customer. You know they are guarding that fountain like a hawk. That's not cool. 1 ⭐ removed. Sitting at our table waiting for the food to come wasn't terrible. The $10 subs came out fast but weren't as full as I hoped. The bread to filling ratio was two notches off and it was an okay sub. Nothing incredible that I'd want to come back for. Minus 1 ⭐. The medium $19 stromboli came out 10 mins later and it looked fantastic. Kid was happy, so I was happy. Add a ⭐. The owner was nice and it appeared he did most of the work at the shop from the cooking to the cleaning. The cashier stayed behind the counter doing light duties, like handing out overpriced styrofoam cups, ketchup packets, and pizza boxes. Seemed off balance. The shop wasn't particularly busy on a Friday night. All in all it's not a bad place to grab a quick bite as long as it's to go. Skip the subs, get...

This was 1 of my favorite places to eat at before I moved away. I was one of their best regular customers before I left. The food is awesome still and yes prices has gone up but that's everywhere. I still feel like u get your money's worth on majority of the items that's on the menu. Extremely friendly and awesome customer service. They will accommodate a disabled or handicapped person without anyone ridiculing you or making fun of you. With what ever accommodations that you may need. They make everyone feel like they belong regardless what their situation is. Nice and very clean atmosphere. The bathrooms are always spotless, clean, and smells good. Everytime i have used their bathroom its always fully stocked and never be out which is refreshing. I'm back I will most definitely be a regular customer again. I highly...

To start, they were very polite on the phone, and made sure to repeat the order back to ensure it was correct. I was greeted with smiles and a very positive attitude as soon as I walked in, which not many places seem to do anymore. Both ladies working there made it an awesome experience.

I ordered a large pepperoni, a California cheese steak and a order of fries. Everything was very well made, exactly how I wanted it. The pizza had great flavor and they weren't stingy with the pepperoni. The fries were crispy and plentiful. My sub was above average but not the best I've ever had, the lettuce tasted a little old and it could have used some more meat, but nonetheless it was good.

I would recommend Marcello's over any other pizza...