I would give them a C+. The reason for this was mostly the service. There were two cashiers and one customer at the counter. I stood behind the customer waiting to pay for my purchase while the other cashier appeared to be busy. Perhaps she was, but there was no acknowledgement that I was there until I had a choice, just before the other customer turned to leave. I didn't feel welcome, mostly just tolerated. The selection of earrings was mediocre. I bought one pair, which was thrown into a bag and when I went to take it out of my pocket back in my car I managed to spear my thumb on one of the posts. That probably added to my overall feelings about the store. In contrast, up the road in Williamsburg there is a store with 10 times the selection of earrings, who always ask if I would like a box. Since they are never for me, but always given as a gift, I always take the box. Maybe that's why I never spear my thumb on their earrings. I will continue shopping there. Probably made my one and only visit to Cedar Chest.