I walked in at random. Was so pleasantly surprised by the wonderful and unique collection, all price ranges included. Ended up falling in love with a pair of earrings that cost more than I was considering to spend, but could afford and I was considering. The woman helping me said she would hold onto them and let me think about it and come back if I like. So warm and earnest. Not trying to force the purchase on me. Anyway, there was no need as I said I would take them! But her serene, friendly way made the experience 11/10. I’ll be happy to visit this shop any time I am...
Read moreEXCEPTIONAL experiences at Starfish Jewelry! I have bought a few items and ALL have surpassed expectations. ALSO, Starfish Jewelry went BEYOND the pale in customer service: this August I bought a lovely Dean Davidson ring, and the moonstone popped free the very day I bought it. Elizabeth was SO HELPFUL: Dean Davidson guarantees all his jewelry for lifetime, so I brought it back, and within the WEEK, Dean Davidson is shipping the ring back to me, repaired. THANK YOU! I will continue to come in and enjoy the incredible pieces you...
Read moreElizabeth at Starfish Jewelry is truly a gem, no pun intended. She helped me pick out the most beautiful, one-of-a-kind, handmade pearl earrings for my wedding and was such a pleasure to work with. I even showed her my dress, my shoe ideas, and got her opinion on necklace options, a veil, how to prepare for my dress fitting, and more. She was so sweet, funny, welcoming, and helpful, and really helped me feel less nervous about my big day. Thank you, Elizabeth! I’ll always remember this experience of buying pearls on...
Read more