Protestant Cay — Local services in United States Virgin Islands

During our trip we stayed at Hotel On The Cay and had a chance to check out other beach areas. Besides the Buck Island, I think this is the best spot to go for swimming. There's a bit more space to spread people around without laying too close to each other in compare to other beach on the island. Furthermore, onsite there are beach chairs, umbrellas and food that are available for a fee (as well as a restroom).

The only downside is when holidays comes around everyone seem to flock on this beach and can get pretty noisy. We saw a few people drunk and loud music blaring to a point that it became annoying. Other than that, this is likely the best spot for a beach day...

The only reason I gave this 2 stars is a great building and beach outside inside very disappointing bed ok bath not so great no water working in bathroom sink had asked for it to be fixed nothing in 4 days AC very noisy floor by mini fridge filthy also clock had no power cord the best part was the water ferry and Jason the operator very friendly and helpful other operators rather rude also no food on island or drinks available always had to ferry over to mainland that about sums up my stay at hotel on...

Beach Hotel on the Cay is a fantastic spot! It has a small restaurant, and you can rent chairs and umbrellas for a comfortable day. We loved the beach and had an amazing time there. Just keep in mind, bringing your own cooler isn’t allowed. A great place to relax and enjoy the sun!

On the other hand, Hotel on the Cay is not as advertised online. The property is in serious need of renovations, the pool is out of service, and there is no on-site restaurant. Disappointing compared to...