Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza Buckhead — Restaurant in Atlanta

We are in town for the weekend and stumbled upon Mister 01 on Google because it was close to our Airbnb – and WOW, what an amazing find! This was hands-down one of the best dining experiences we have ever had anywhere.

From the moment we walked in, the staff was warm, friendly, and so attentive. It was genuinely impressive to watch them all work together like a well-orchestrated team. Dishes and glasses were cleared immediately, tables were reset within seconds of guests leaving, and even when the staff wasn’t actively serving, they stood along the back wall with pleasant smiles, scanning the room and staying ready to help. It felt like watching a perfectly choreographed dance — so organized and intentional.

Our server, Imari, was absolutely outstanding. She greeted us with the kind of energy that instantly makes you feel at home. She was patient, kind, and clearly knew the menu inside and out. She gave us spot-on recommendations, shared the back story of Mister 01, and even checked in at just the right moments — never intrusive, but always there before we had to ask. She genuinely seemed to care that we had a great experience, and she made us feel like VIP guests the entire time.

We ordered the Caesar salad and the Star Meat Lovers pizza, and both were incredible. The Caesar salad was huge (could easily feed six people) and absolutely delicious. Everything was served quickly and with such attention to detail. The ingredients were clearly top-notch — the olive oil and balsamic were imported from Italy and you could taste the difference in every bite. They even brought out a bottle of imported spicy olive oil for the pizza, which was next-level good.

The whole experience felt thoughtfully curated, almost like being back in Europe. If you are anywhere near this place, do yourself a favor and go. And if you can, ask for Imari — she made an already amazing night...

Mister O Extraordinary Pizza – A Slice of Heaven on Earth!

From the moment you step into Mister O Extraordinary Pizza, you know you’re not in an ordinary pizza joint — you’re in the presence of greatness. The aroma alone could make angels weep. Mister O doesn’t just make pizza… he creates edible masterpieces that redefine what pizza should be.

Let’s talk crust. Golden. Crispy. Chewy in all the right ways. Each bite crackles with just the right amount of resistance before melting into buttery bliss. It’s the kind of crust that could win awards — if it hasn’t already.

And the sauce? Oh. My. Goodness. Tangy, savory, with a whisper of sweetness and herbs that dance like poetry on your tongue. It’s not just sauce — it’s the soul of the pizza.

The toppings? Fresh like they were handpicked from a secret garden just moments before hitting the oven. Whether you’re a classic pepperoni person or a bold adventurer trying the “O-M-G Supreme,” every ingredient sings in perfect harmony.

And don’t even get me started on the cheese. Stretchy, gooey, golden perfection. It’s the cheese-pull dreams are made of.

Service? Impeccable. Friendly smiles, quick service, and a vibe that makes you feel like family the moment you walk in. Mister O himself might even swing by your table to check in — and when he does, it’s like meeting the Picasso of pizza.

This isn’t just a restaurant — it’s a legend in the making. Whether you’re a local or a traveler passing through, Mister O Extraordinary Pizza is a must-stop destination. You’ll leave full, happy, and already planning...

It is so nice to finally have good, flavorful pizza in Georgia! Coming from South Florida where we were spoiled with amazing pizza and originally from New York, I’ve been on the hunt for almost 4 years since moving here—and I’ve finally found “the one.”

My sister, who still lives in South Florida, told me about Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza and their Sandy Springs location, but when she came to visit, we went to their brand new Buckhead location that opened on July 1. It completely blew us away.

The food was perfection. Every single thing we ordered was cooked and seasoned just right. The pizza crust is light, crispy, and packed with flavor—not heavy or greasy like so many other places around here.

Must-try recommendations: Marco’s Pizza (even my husband, who doesn’t like pizza, loved this one!) Caesar Salad (so fresh and flavorful) Margarita Pizza Coffee Paolo (a flavor combination you have to try!) And if you have room… the Nutella Pizza and Nutella Banana Calzone are out of this world.

On top of the amazing food, the service was just as exceptional. The owner, Miguel, made us feel like family, our server was attentive and kind, and they even gave teddy bears to the kids. Such a thoughtful and memorable experience.

Now with two Georgia locations, Sandy Springs and Buckhead, I’m thrilled to finally have my pizza fix covered here in Atlanta and when I visit my family in Florida. The kids said it deserves 10 stars and honestly, I wish I could give more than 5. I hope they open one in the Peachtree City...