Peoples Pizza of Cherry Hill — Restaurant in Cherry Hill Township

I have never ordered from them before and I ordered over the phone, 2 panzarottis, one with meatball and raw onion and one extra cheese. When I went to pick them up and it came to $24.58, I looked at their menu and noticed they had 2 sizes, large and small. Large was $9.99. I asked the guy at the counter, "did you give me 2 large panzarottis?" He said "yes, if you dont specify what size when you order, we give you a large" I said "ok because I never ordered from you before so I wouldn't know you had 2 sizes." Pretty sneaky if you ask me. How hard is it for them to say "small or large"? Then when I got home, they marked one as "mtbl" so you would only assume the other was extra cheese then, right? Wrong. As I started to eat what I thought was the meatball and onion one I noticed there was nothing in it but mounds of cheese. I opened the unmarked one and sure enough, it was the meatball and onion one. Thank goodness someone that was a vegetarian or even worse allergic to onions wasn't the one that started eating the meatball and onion one thinking it was extra cheese. Also, I ordered them fried not baked and I'm pretty sure these were baked because they weren't crispy at all. Really doughy, almost like an undercooked pizza folded in half and very hard to cut through. I had actually wanted to order from Francos in Westmont but they were already closed and since I was in the Cherry Hill area I thought I'd give People's Pizza a try. First and last time I'll be going...

Placed an order on their website for pick up. Paid on line received texts from Peoples Pizza telling me to pick up is at 9:05pm. Arrived at 9:08pm and they were closed. The next day I went into the restaurant to speak with the owner explained what happened asked for a refund or credit. He directed me to DoorDash said not his problem! I have no idea why DoorDash since I placed the order for pick up not DoorDash! He confirmed he received my money, that he had my phone number and never called me, YET never provided the food I paid for! He was not only less than helpful but was rude, condescending, and raised his voice at me!! I USE to be a customer! NO LONGER. Think twice about giving your business to someone who doesn’t hesitate to treat female customers with disrespect! He’s a business owner who is willing to take your money but not provide the service you paid for!! Plenty of other pizza places in Cherry Hill..GO ANYWHERE but...

I enjoyed this pizza and its sweet sauce. The mozzarella sticks were good, too. The restaurant was very spacious and they really seem like a well oiled machine up there! The ONLY reason I knock off a star, is because the men working in the back decided to come out from behind and STARE at me in my dress and even keep going back and telling each other and just walk back and forth literally staring at me like I was staring at my pizza - with hungry eyes. Made me so uncomfortable I had to go sit down and my husband ordered and came back and expressed how weird and creepy it was and that he didn't call them out because maybe he thought I appreciated the attention. Definitely freaking creepy. So maybe don't wear a cute summer dress when eating here if you have curves. Good pizza, nice seating, creepy people. Wouldn't come back BUT glad I came and enjoyed my food...