Jack's Seafood
Jack's Seafood things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
Ordered fried mushroom appetizer in the form of an ala carté togo lunchy/snack-type situation. The batter was appropriate to the vegetable being fried and sufficiently coated the lil' mushies. The sauces were PLENTIFUL and varied. All told, the amount of saprophytes served up equaled exactly 9. Approx 180g average cost =1$. The number of ramekins filled with sauces equaled 3. Approx 5oz total (Chipotle mayo and Ranch) $= +/- .50. The improvements that I can see as being needful are: The mushrooms before being battered and abused/fried need to have their stems re-cut, as time turns these initial "harvesting" cuts at the foot of the shrooms somewhat woody, and frying this tougher piece of the stalk inside a battered shell along with some resident moisture from the mushroom itself lends to the "foot" of the mushroom texture and tooth of a slimy scab😢(sad face). The mushrooms were cooked perfectly, thankfully. As any variances in temperature can ruin the tender fellas. There were 9 individual fried fungal reproductive parts in my order, which came to 10$(menu price, 13$ including tip). And I always add the tip to the total on the restaurants end. As the only reason tipping is necessary is because restaurants are still paying floorstaff minimum wage, when they should've raised pay rates commensurate to cost of living/inflation increases rather than put the burden of care on the public, their customers. But that's what the masses are for; carrying the burden of budget cuts, and rising rates so that the profit margin may stay somewhat stable, and knowable. (I wish I would've been asked first 😜) The service I received was perfect. Attentive, pleasant, and polite. Doing the math the lil guys came to around $1.44 each. Almost a buck fifty a piece for an item that was first (skillfully)dropped in batter, then (skillfully)dropped into the fryer, and then finally(skillfully)dropped onto a plate. I was not as disappointed (tho, the amount of mushrooms I received this time in comparison to the last time(2 years ago) was a little disheartening) as much as I was not surprised that whomever is making the calls regarding pricing and portions has decided to take the easy route in navigating these interesting financial times. I figure that I could've just put down "9 mushrooms for 13$" and left it at that, but I doubt that review would have the intended effect
Oh Boy!Oh Boy!
00
So we are on a road trip and we came to Eureka craving seafood. You would think that you would be able to get good seafood and a good bowl of clam chowder on the California coast, they were out, but Jack's proved us wrong. Let's start off with a poor service from the very beginning and the fact that we watched them serve several other people who were seated after. Some people who seated 10 minutes after us their order was taken and they were halfway done with their drinks before we were finally able to flag somebody down to take our order. You would think you couldn't screw up a crab sandwich or a shrimp po-boy but Jacks again proved us wrong. The crab sandwich was tasteless and canned crab for $20 which was an absolute rip off, and 13 french fries. The shrimp po-boy, incredibly small portion, which was $17, and an absolute ripoff. And supposed to be shrimp but we're pretty sure was a switch a roo with calamari and exactly 11 French fries. And yes we counted. Service was atrocious. We will never go back. It's very rare that you sit in a restaurant eating the food you paid for, and trying to track down a KFC so that you can go get a chicken sandwich. Is pretty pathetic that a seafood restaurant would stay open on a Monday when most other seafood restaurants are closed, so that they can take advantage of unaware vacationers coming through town. I can guarantee no locals eat here. Run far away from Jacks.
Douglas JudsonDouglas Judson
00
First of all, the restaurant was clean and it smelled good. The atmosphere was comfortable and clean. The waitress was awesome! She was prompt and courteous, and she was very knowledgeable. The food was awesome! If you like oysters, they had some delicious oysters that were baked and / or prepared in the half shell. They had delicious flavors. Although a little spendy. It's pretty much the going price everywhere. Everything on the menu sounded absolutely delicious. It made it a little difficult to decide. We ordered fish and chips meal with jumbo shrimp and halibut. But they did give you the choice to order Cod instead of halibut. They had a wonderful selection of soups. We had a miso mushroom soup, and my niece had the clam chowder. She was very happy with that also. The oyster appetizers were delicious. I want to go back there soon and I want to get the lump crab sandwich! It sounded so delicious, so if you want to check out the menu, it's online, and they are more items when you go to the restaurant . Look at the menu
mary popamary popa
00
1. Food was not as good as I expected. It was a seafood restaurant but my clam liguini was more of a pasta bowl and small serving of clams. (The clams were on the top so it was looking like it had more clams). 2. We were welcomed with flies (this was indoor seating). 3. It is noticable that our server was over worked as he had the whole section in our corner. 4. Worst, the Asian lady brought out our food and served it in the next seating. She didnt wait to confirm it with the costumer. The guy called her back to say they never ordered the linguine. They did order the fish/calamari so she left the plate to them but they got the plate with spicy coleslaw and my husband got the nonspicy. (He ordered the spicy). The Asian lady took back the liguini and then came back later to serve it to us. I wasnt sure if it was touched but I didnt want to return it as I wasnt sure if I am going to win the battle and I was really hungry. Do not recommend this place.
A. MutyaA. Mutya
00
We were able to get an outside table and the atmosphere was perfect. Watching boats come in and out was a lot of fun and the weather was perfect. The food was mediocre at best. Salads looked good, but the soup was just OK. Butter that came with the bread was good but the bread was plain. Calamari had very little flavor and was chewy. The sauces that came with it were unusual. We weren't given any salt and pepper so we found it for ourselves on a nearby cart. We had shrimp and grilled fish tacos both were good, but dry and the sauce that was served with them was just salsa. We also had Alfredo and it was watery. Like a noodle and milk soup. The 5 scallops included in the scallop dish were the best thing we had. Service was slow and we had to keep requesting drink refills. Overall, food is just OK, but priced too high, service is slow and atmosphere outside was great!
Jessica EdgmonJessica Edgmon
00
Absolutely LOVE this restaurant! Fresh seafood perfectly prepared and delicious! Friendly service, too! While eating here we watched a trawler offload several hundred pounds of live crabs just behind Jack's. Can't get much fresher than that. Photos & video below. They do have a large separate room for large parties, two guest bathrooms as well as highchairs and booster seats for the kiddos. Oh, and a well stocked bar for the grown-ups. In the steps-away free parking lot there are two ChargePoint Level 2 chargers. Cost varies by time of day. Highly recommend Jack's!
James BrayJames Bray
00
Nearby Attractions Of Jack's Seafood
Best Western Plus Humboldt Bay Inn
Grocery Outlet
Eureka Inn Trademark By Wyndham
Inn at 2nd & C
Platinum Studio Salon and Float Spa
Madaket Harbor Cruise
Town House Motel - Historic Old Town
Arkley Center for the Performing Arts
Booklegger
The Eureka Theater

Best Western Plus Humboldt Bay Inn
4.4
(794)Click for details

Grocery Outlet
4.2
(578)Click for details

Eureka Inn Trademark By Wyndham
4.0
(373)Click for details

Inn at 2nd & C
4.5
(320)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Jack's Seafood
Bayfront Restaurant
Café Marina & Woodley's Bar
Kristina's Restaurant
Los Bagels
Gallagher's Restaurant & Pub
Café Waterfront
Lost Coast Brewery & Cafe
A A Bar & Grill
Paul’s Live From Ny Pizza
Sea Grill

Bayfront Restaurant
4.2
(689)$$
Click for details

Café Marina & Woodley's Bar
4.1
(678)Click for details

Kristina's Restaurant
4.3
(669)Click for details

Los Bagels
4.4
(584)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
4 C St, Eureka, CA 95501
Map
Phone
(707) 273-5273
Call
Website
jackseafoodeureka.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.1
(450 reviews)
Ratings & Description
attractions: Best Western Plus Humboldt Bay Inn, Grocery Outlet, Eureka Inn Trademark By Wyndham, Inn at 2nd & C, Platinum Studio Salon and Float Spa, Madaket Harbor Cruise, Town House Motel - Historic Old Town, Arkley Center for the Performing Arts, Booklegger, The Eureka Theater, restaurants: Bayfront Restaurant, Café Marina & Woodley's Bar, Kristina's Restaurant, Los Bagels, Gallagher's Restaurant & Pub, Café Waterfront, Lost Coast Brewery & Cafe, A A Bar & Grill, Paul’s Live From Ny Pizza, Sea Grill

- Please manually select your location for better experience