Incredibly disappointing ice cream. The shop itself is inviting and super pleasant to visit. And the employees seem happy and are quick with the orders.
But the ice cream? Hard pass. Will NOT be back. Both flavors I tried were completely unremarkable, but even worse was the icy, gritty texture. It was borderline like eating a SnoCone. Best case scenario? The 2 flavors I had (cookie dough and brownie chip) were just part of a bad batch, there was something wrong with the freezer, or the freezer temp was too low. Worst case? The ice cream passed all quality checks and this is actually how they sell it. Either way, this is not what small batch ice cream should be.
Finally, even if the ice cream was fantastic (which it wasn't), the scoops were embarrassingly small. They weren't nicely shaped scoops either. If you put the exact ice cream I got side by side with the Turkey Hill/Breyer's/etc equivalents from the grocery store and had any random passerby scoop them for you I guarantee that 9 out of 10 people would take the grocery store ice cream. Especially if you tell them it's $8 for 2 scoops of Tabitha's vs $5 for a whole quart of the...
Read moreThree words: ICE CREAM FLIGHT. The flavors are all so amazing and deliciously fresh and creative, how can you possibly choose just one? No problem: get yourself an ice cream flight and enjoy a scoop of FOUR different flavors at once!!! BRILLIANT!!! Plus there are Italian ice and sorbet options. The shop is also so cute, clean and the service was amazing. Go...
Read moreThis is THE. BEST. PLACE…to stop for Ice Cream!!! Sue is THE. AWESOMEST. PERSON. you will ever meet!! So full of life and just a treat to be around. Much like the ice cream she serves at Tabitha’s! If you want an amazing experience with Ive Cream Flavors that are out of this world!!! Go to...
Read more