Jersey Mike's Subs — Restaurant in Flemington

Normally I wouldn’t write a review but I feel as though I had to this time. My mother went and picked up a Giant #13 for us for dinner. Upon opening it, right away I noticed it didn’t look as full as it normally does. For it being the “giant” size, there should’ve been more meat for sure, and I didn’t even see two of the meats that were supposed to be on there. Now I will say we didn’t get cheese, onion, or tomato, however that does not take up much room on the bread. I always order it like this and today it was so disappointingly thin. Not to mention the balance for the oil and vinegar to go cup was way too oily. The taste was still great, but the bread wasn’t totally up to par. I normally go to the Clinton location as it’s closer and I am never disappointed, but today we gave Flemington a shot because it was more convenient. Don’t think I will be coming back to this location especially if the amount of meat on a $20 sub...

Place is going downhill. First, the hours were changed and they close very early at 7pm. Sub sizes have gotten smaller. The 'giant' sub is smaller and prices higher (understand this is due to rising gas prices). The past few visits there have been issues with our orders. Last night I ordered the #14 Vege mini for my wife who is a vegetarian. When I got home she said that the sub was missing Onions, Tomatoes, Lettuce, and Green Bell pepper. It is supposed to have: White Bread, Onions, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Red Wine Vinegar, Olive Oil Blend, Oregano, Salt, Green Bell Pepper. What a disappointment. She had to throw the sub out as she literally had a one cheese sandwich. Cost us $6.56. In addition, the employees are only using 1 slicer - the other slicer sits idle. And if you ask for other cheeses, they do not understand that you cannot use the same slicer as meat for vegetarians. They only had American white...

So…I love Jersey Mike sandwiches.. I buy it weekly for family and friends. I also love to have it on my lunch breaks. This was my first visit to this store location…and had the worst experience. I placed my order on the app and called in as well to request “all meat cooked well done”. I got there on time and waited for order to be ready. My order of five hot subs got dumped on the register. I stood for about 10mins unattended, while the associate at the register went about chatting carelessly while intentionally ignoring me…it was the manager who asked him, where was my order? to which this associate obnoxiously responded “I was not the one who made the sandwich” 🤦🏾‍♀️ Anyways, sup or manager (not sure) was kind enough to hand me my order. Perhaps serving a colored girl was too much for him....