The SugarMill, Inc. — Restaurant in Georgia

I discovered them from a coworker. I had never heard of them or been here but she said they had awesome desserts & from the pictures & reviews I'd figure I'd give them a try. I needed 50 cupcakes for my fiancee's bday party I called & dealt with Cyrus the Monday before the party. I was having an issue getting the invoice so I couldn't pay ahead of time. Me & cyrus had never dealt with each other before but he still made the 50 cupcakes for me without me paying for them ahead of time. I was beyond shocked seeing that I was getting 5 diff flavors . Anyways fast forward to this past Saturday I went to pick them up, opened the box they all looked & smelled amazing. I didn't actually have one until I brought them out for the party. Every single cupcake seemed to be made with pure love & sugar. . EVERYYYYYONEEEEE loved the cupcakes . As soon as I opened the boxes I blinked & they were gone so fast! Lol thank you so much cyrus for these cupcakes my personal favorite was the key lime. . . Mainly because i didn't even get to try any other ones they were gone so fast. I will def use you all for future events & you've made a customer out of me...

I grew up in a family business of cakes and this is the only place I have been able to find that compares to what I grew up with. Do I pay a little more than I would for the cheap Publix slice? Yes. But does it taste so much better than the cheapy? Heck yes. I make this a treat for myself, especially when Mocha is available (the best one!). I also like the carrot cake, mainly bc it doesn't leave weird crumbs in my mouth and the frosting with it is perfect. I also hate a ton of frosting, but the slices always have just enough for me.

They also have some great cupcakes, which are a favorite of my sisters (the oreo ones!). I like their baked goods too and sometimes will leave with a cinnamon roll or two.

Seriously, this is a family owned business that is worth a visit! If you have a favorite, make sure you call ahead and check. Also, they are closed on Sundays, so make sure you get your...

I picked up a variety of different cakes yesterday and I was not a fan of any of them. It tasted like box cake mix with box icing nothing stood out to me and they did not taste homemade at all. My husband and I was not a fan of the icing on any of the cakes we didn’t finish any of them the cake in itself tasted old and very dry. When I originally picked them up I thought I had finally found a great desert place in Conyers but this one was not it! The cupcakes were MINI when I thought they would be homemade fluffy and jumbo cupcakes. I just feel I could of got better at maybe public or Ingles for the prices and the quality of the cakes. It says made fresh daily but I know for a fact what I received was everything from the day before because my sister had checked to see what kind of cakes they had for...