Olde Dutch
Olde Dutch things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
As a restaurant critic, I have to say that my recent experience at the Olde Dutch was quite disappointing. From start to finish, there were several issues that left a bad taste in my mouth, both literally and figuratively. Firstly, the ambiance of the restaurant was unimpressive and outdated. The decor and furniture were tired and worn, and the lighting was dim, creating a rather gloomy atmosphere. It felt like the restaurant was stuck in the past and had not made any effort to update its style or décor. The service was also subpar, with our server seeming disinterested and unenthusiastic about their job. We had to wait a long time for our food to arrive, and when it finally did, it was underwhelming. The dishes lacked flavor and were not properly seasoned, making them taste bland and unappetizing. To make matters worse, the prices were too high for the quality of food and service we received. It felt like we were paying a premium just for the name and reputation of the restaurant, rather than the actual experience we had. Overall, I cannot recommend the Olde Dutch. There are many other restaurants in the area that offer better food, service, and ambiance for a similar or even lower price point. If you're looking for a memorable dining experience, I would suggest looking elsewhere.
JoToJoTo
30
We typically eat Millstone when we're in Logan. So we decided to give this a go for lunch, and eat millstone for dinner. 4 stars overall, here is individual breakdown. What I tried! Broasted chicken 5 stars Pork lion 5 stars Mashed potatoes and beef gravy 5 stars Beef sirloin steak 3 star as in eatable lacked any seasoning so it was bland. Scalloped potatoes 2 star scalloped potatoes have to taste cheesy. Stufffing 4 star Chocolate creamy pie 5 stars easily Hot apple crisp 5 star easily My wife had Turkey was good she had seconds Pork lion was good She had noodles over mashed potatoes she had seconds Corn was good Cheesy penne was decent She liked the chocolate cream pie and the Dutch Apple pie. We would def visit again. Didn't take long to be seated at 1:50pm. Only mess up was we both went to buffet and the manager thought we left and cleared our table for some one who said we left and they wanted our table. This was quickly taken care of and we resumed eating. Lesson alternate trips to buffet line.
Ricky MooreheadRicky Moorehead
00
The Old Dutch restaurant has to be one of the best buffets in Ohio. If you like the Amish buffets in Berlin and Sugarcreek, I guarantee you will like this one better. This buffet has more homemade dishes, and they use more spices for flavor. The buffet even had General Tso's chicken, and I was a bit leery, but tried it, anyway. Boy, was I surprised. The chicken was crispy on the outside and tender in the middle. The sauce was perfect with a pinch of heat. Not sure I've had this good of General Tso's in the better Chinese restaurants. Love the broasted chicken. I noticed some people commented on all the unhealthy fried food, but I saw plenty of healthy choices, including turkey, lean beef roast, Brussel sprouts, green beans, and salads. The broasted chicken would be healthy if you take off the skin. Desserts were plentiful and not limited to pies. They also have ice creams available. Today, they had vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry. The price is $14.99...not including the drink.
Beth LBeth L
10
I had the pleasure of dining at this Amish buffet after an exhausting 8-mile hike, and it was the perfect reward for my tired legs. The variety of dishes they offered was impressive, ranging from chicken and beef to pork, shrimp, and fish. Just a heads up, though, soda isn’t included in the buffet. When it comes to dessert, they didn’t disappoint either. I savored a delightful selection of pies and cakes that truly hit the sweet spot. But what made this dining experience truly exceptional was the host’s warm and welcoming smile, along with their lightning-fast service. It’s those little touches that make a meal memorable. Parking was a breeze with ample space, and they even had a gift shop on-site, adding to the charm of the place. Plus, if you’re up for it, there’s an antique store nearby, making it a perfect spot to walk off all that delicious food. I highly recommend this Amish buffet for a satisfying post-hike feast with great service and some added shopping options.
HarryHarry
00
This restaurant is always crowded and for good reason - the food is excellent. I’m not a big buffet person but because we had 16 people we all ordered the buffet. All the food was fresh and replenished frequently. And, there was a ton of different foods. The best was the broasted chicken. Everyone in our party loved the chicken. There was also roasted Turkey, salmon, fried shrimp, roast beef, pulled pork, mashed potatoes, green beans, Brussel sprouts, corn, beets, gravy, fresh rolls, macaroni and cheese, noodles, stuffed peppers, chicken pasta, salad bar, macaroni salad, Cole slaw and a full dessert bar which had a variety of pies and ice cream on request. They also had sugar free options. Our waitress (who was our only waitress) was so good. Our glasses were never empty. As you walk in there is a gift shop with tons of reasonably priced merchandise missy of which focused around the hocking hills.
bobbie Stonerockbobbie Stonerock
00
People usually give out 5 stars if the restaurant is good. But this place is a true 5 stars , or even 6 stars. Amish buffet, nothing special you think. $15 for buffet and comes with dessert. They make sure everything is filled even 20mins before they close. Salad bar has real greens instead of just iceberg lettuce. They serve food that sit well on the heater, so the quality doesn't go down when it been sitting there. Service is top notch. Everyone is so nice and polite. I don't know where they find these teenagers from. Better than chic Fila and you know everyone raves about their service. And what buffet you been to has a free petting zoo and mimi golf next to it. Mimi golf is only $10 for a day . If you been camping in Hocking hills or just drove by, you have to visit this place.
FriedChickenFriedChicken
40
Nearby Attractions Of Olde Dutch
Hocking Hills Canoe Livery
Hocking Hills Adventures
Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan, an IHG Hotel
Hocking Mall
Adventure Golf at Rempel's Grove
MainStay Suites Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills
Lake Logan Inn
Midwest Glassware Outlet

Hocking Hills Canoe Livery
4.8
(520)Click for details

Hocking Hills Adventures
4.3
(481)Click for details

Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan, an IHG Hotel
4.3
(458)Click for details

Hocking Mall
4.1
(205)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Olde Dutch
Millstone Southern Smoked BBQ
Pearl's Diner
Cristy's Pizza Logan
DQ Logan (Dairy Queen)
Los Amigos
Bob Evans
Grand Buffet
McDonald's
Arby's
Taco Bell

Millstone Southern Smoked BBQ
4.3
(2.6K)Click for details

Pearl's Diner
4.4
(277)Click for details

Cristy's Pizza Logan
4.4
(242)Click for details

DQ Logan (Dairy Queen)
3.9
(432)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
12791 OH-664, Logan, OH 43138
Map
Phone
(740) 385-1000
Call
Website
theoldedutchrestaurant.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.5
(2.5K reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Family-friendly operation serving Amish-style comfort food, either à la carte & or at the buffet.
attractions: Hocking Hills Canoe Livery, Hocking Hills Adventures, Holiday Inn Express Hocking Hills-Logan, an IHG Hotel, Hocking Mall, Adventure Golf at Rempel's Grove, MainStay Suites Logan Ohio-Hocking Hills, Lake Logan Inn, Midwest Glassware Outlet, restaurants: Millstone Southern Smoked BBQ, Pearl's Diner, Cristy's Pizza Logan, DQ Logan (Dairy Queen), Los Amigos, Bob Evans, Grand Buffet, McDonald's, Arby's, Taco Bell
