Rosati's Pizza — Restaurant in New Berlin

So last time I ordered a Chicago style pizza from here they gave me a pizza that was completely raw. So today I gave them another chance but ordering a thin crust so it would be cooked thoroughly. I got less than expected. While I was eating I thought the topping was great but it had an odd texture. The more towards the middle pieces I got it was just slimy and I noticed raw yet again. Now I've been getting food from them for awhile now the 2 most prior incidents have really turned me away from ordering a pizza ever again from here. I called and was upset but by them serving me raw dough I can get sick. That can cause ecoli and I dont have time to be sick or worry about getting sick. The manager I spoke with was very rude and said he cut it himself and it looked fine. The thing is though it wasnt fine. I told him about the potential of getting people sick, i was offered a credit but I can guarantee it will not be used on pizza. The part that irritates me most is he wanted to argue about the pizza not being raw. I offered him to come pick it up. Hes more than welcome to come stick his finger in it and see its raw. Even when I look at the bottom it has no darkening of being cooked throughly. Here are some photos of what was under my...

I’m from out of town but have ordered from here many times. I absolutely love their pizzas. We recently ordered from Rosatis again and we ordered a few pizzas along with other items. I have not had a Chicago style pizza in a while and absolutely loved Rosati’s Chicago style pizza. It was thick, packed full of tomato sauce, cheese, pepperoni and sausage. I wished we had ordered two Chicago style pizzas as we devoured it quite quickly as a group. It was delightful like I remember Chicago style pizza I ate in college. Our other pizzas and bread sticks were great as well.

I also love chicken Parmesan sandwiches and feel I have to try them if they are on any menu. Rosati’s chicken Parmesan was okay but not the highlight of our order. I’ve definitely had better at other places.

We ordered takeout and our food was ready as stated when we placed our order.

I would recommend ordering from Rosati’s and look forward to the next time we visit family and order...

This restaurant is amazing!! Best customer service I've received in a long time. I wish I could give the owner a hug.

I placed an order at pizza hut for my son's birthday party, 2 days ahead of time, and they canceled my order the day of. I didn't find out it was canceled until 10 min after the scheduled delivery time. Apparently they were too busy to make the order...

I panicked! I had 10 hungry people to feed!

And then I ordered at Rosati's. This place is the real deal. Excellent customer service. Not only were they able to accommodate my order on short notice, but they sent plates, napkins, and spatulas along as well. And the pizzas... OMG! They are delicious and soooo big!

This place saved my son's birthday party! Thank you so very much. I'm a Rosati's...