Jacob's Pickles — Restaurant in New York

What a great restaurant!!!!! Such GREAT FOOD!!!! I LOVED it!!! We came here for Sunday Early Dinner (Yesterday), and I can't honestly wait to be back.

This place is one of the greatest/best restaurants I've been to. Starting with the atmosphere, you feel great, they are all so welcoming, so polite, so attentive. It is simply awesome!! Then, the music will have you dancing in your seat the whole time you're here cause IT'S LIT!!!!! Such a great playlist, loved it too. Haha

We were greeted by Lance, since I had a reservation he had us seated right away. Lance was very impressive and he gives out such a good vibe. Then our waiter, Jordan, came to the table to bring us water and napkins. I have their names in my notes, as I always try to recognize the staff when they do such a good work, Jordan is in my notes as " Jordan - BEST waiter EVER!!!!". Hahaha! He really was the best, he would come to our table every 8-10 minutes to make sure everything was perfect. Loved how professional yet friendly and attentive he was, hope he's there to serve us whenever I come back!

Food wise, everything was so perfect, so delicious and the portions are gigantic. We started with the Poutine (added bacon to it), it was MOUTHWATERING, the combination of every ingredient was divine. Then we ordered Buffalo Mac and Cheese and Classic Mac and Cheese (w/Bacon), we got entree size and it was such a huge mistake, I had 4 bites and couldn't eat any other bite after that. My boyfriend finished almost half of his Buffalo Mac and he was struggling to eat more cause it was so good but his body couldn't take any more. We ended up filling up three containers to "take home", not one, not two, THREE!! We took two to my boyfriend's mom and one home, it was so much food it's CRAYCRAY!

I really wish to be back on Brunch and try other delicious options.

Really loved this restaurant, loved the ambiance, loved the food, and the service was definitely the cherry on top! Come and rate if you have the chance. 1,000,000% recommended!!!!!!!!

P.S.: Forgot to mention their AWESOME, DELICIOUS Fried Oreos. They were the BEST Fried Oreos we’ve had. They were crispy all over, sweet but not overwhelming. The batter was light so you get to enjoy the taste of the oreo more than the batter. They were finger licking delicious!!!

GET THE FRIED OREOS!!! GET THE FRIED OREOS!!! GET THE FRIED...

I will caveat my review that I think I may have ordered poorly for me. We had a booking for Saturday night at 5:45 and when we arrived the restaurant was already packed. We were shown to our table quickly which was good.

The drinks menu has a great selection for both alcoholic and non alcoholic options (I am doing dry January at the moment so having good NA options is important to me at the moment). I was torn between a few of the biscuit sandwiches and our server recommended the chicken honey and pickle sandwich. I mentioned that I didn't like pickles (I know, I am at a place with pickles in the name!) and he said they could be put on the side so I went ahead and ordered. My friend ordered the catfish tacos and mac and cheese. The food arrived quickly and the portions were huge, you could definitely share these if you had had any other meal that day. My pickles were on the side so I cut into my chicken and it was so sweet! Like overwhelmingly sweet to the point that it was all I could taste. I am sure the pickles are supposed to cut through that sweetness so this is why I say I think I ordered incorrectly. The batter on the chicken was lovely and the chicken itself was well cooked, I just struggled to eat it due to the sweetness. Eventually I cut off the batter that was soaked in honey and tried to eat around it (with some hot sauce on top to try and counter the sweet). My friend said her catfish was cooked very well but lost the flavour of the fish a bit due to all of the accompaniments in the tacos. She said the mac and cheeses was very good though (she even took the leftovers home).

We ended the meal with some fried Oreos to share. These were different to fried Oreos that I have had before, the batter was more crispy and less like a doughnut type consistency, and they were very good. The total for my portion of the bill, including tax and tip came to a little over $30 so I think the restaurant is good value. I would return here and try a different dish. Just be warned, if you don't like pickles do not order that honey...

Jacob’s Pickles, located on the Upper West Side of New York City, is a beloved restaurant known for its Southern-inspired comfort food and extensive selection of craft beers and cocktails.

Cuisine: Jacob’s Pickles specializes in hearty Southern comfort food with a modern twist. Signature dishes include fried chicken, biscuits, mac and cheese, and of course, pickles. The fried chicken biscuit sandwich and chicken and pancakes are particularly popular. Many reviews highlight the rich, flavorful dishes and generous portions. The restaurant also offers a variety of house-made pickles that add a unique and tangy touch to many dishes.

Ambiance: The ambiance at Jacob’s Pickles is rustic and cozy, with a welcoming and lively atmosphere. The interior features wooden decor, communal tables, and vintage accents that create a warm, Southern-inspired vibe. The bustling energy of the restaurant makes it a great spot for both casual dining and social gatherings.

Service: Service at Jacob’s Pickles is generally praised for being friendly and attentive. The staff is often described as accommodating and knowledgeable about the menu. Despite the high volume of customers, especially during peak hours, the service is efficient and professional, contributing to a positive dining experience.

Value: Many patrons find Jacob’s Pickles to offer good value for the quality and quantity of food served. While the prices are moderate, the large portions and flavorful dishes make it worth the cost. The restaurant is considered a great option for those looking to indulge in satisfying comfort food without breaking the bank.

Overall Experience: Overall, Jacob’s Pickles is highly regarded for its delicious Southern comfort food, inviting atmosphere, and friendly service. It is a popular destination for brunch, dinner, and late-night eats. The combination of hearty dishes, a cozy setting, and a lively ambiance makes it a favorite among locals and...