Mr Pizza — Restaurant in New York

Pros:

Food is of good quality

Cons:

Nobody answers the phone! Called multiple times to place a pick up order, and the staff didn't answer. THEN I went to place the order in person, and while waiting, their phone went off TWICE and they didn't pick up. It wasn't even busy at the time! Also, they recently jacked up the prices by a BIG amount! Went to order a small pie with toppings, and before it would be around like 6-8 dollars, but when I went to pay, it was $14!? I enjoyed going to this place BECAUSE the price was as good as the quality of the pizza. I get why they jacked up the prices around covid, but there's no reason why they're still as inflated when things are getting better than before! I've been coming here since before they had renovated back in 2011 or 2012. Sad that I now have to...

The typical New York pizza experience has few surprises. You just want a slice or a pie with minimal fuss. Mr. Pizza fits the bill beautifully. The food is delicious and simple. Three things to be aware of:

1. The dining area is pretty cramped, especially when there's a crowd.
2. The entrance is a short but steep flight of stairs, so watch your step!
3. Mr. Pizza has only one phone line, which pulls double duty on delivery orders and their credit card terminal. Don't be surprised if, on busy days, the...

The pizza isn’t perfect here but it isn’t horrible. It’s a decent local spot but not Ruth’s Chris so don’t get your hopes up. I would have given 4 stars but I feel there food quality could be higher. I got 6 piece chicken wings there once and there was no actual chicken on the wings. It was just all fat or breading of some sort. And it cost me $7-8 something like that. For 9.99 you can get 6 pieces from hook and reel and you’ll have plenty of...