Village Square Pizza - Upper West Side — Restaurant in New York

Village Square Pizza offers more than just a meal; it's a slice of home in every bite. The crust, with a delightful combination of crispy edges and a chewy center, sets the stage for a comforting experience.

The sauce is a well-balanced blend of sweetness and tanginess, complemented by a generous layer of gooey, perfectly melted cheese. Toppings are fresh and abundant, showcasing the commitment to quality ingredients.

What truly defines Village Square Pizza is the sense of community within its cozy space. The welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and nostalgic décor create an environment reminiscent of family gatherings around a dinner table.

Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or sharing a whole pie with friends, Village Square Pizza is a cherished spot for locals and a must-visit for those seeking a taste of genuine,...

My pepperoni square was solid. The service was on point - even asking if I would prefer a corner or the middle when I asked for a square slice.

The flavors on the pizza were high quality. I liked the sauce, the crust was crispy, the pepperoni slices had cupped up the way they should.

Having said that, if the pizza is consistently similar to what I had today, I would drop it to four stars. Most of the pizzas had clearly been sitting for a bit. The slice I got was not hot, and the cheese was more of a thin layer of solid cheese, as opposed to the melty goodness I am generally looking for.

But this spot is new, the flavors and quality of ingredients was there, and the guys behind the counter were very service oriented. So I’m hoping the next time I stop in for a $6 slice, the pizza is fresh and piping hot, the way...

Overrated, the squares remind me of mamma’s too but are no where near as good (in terms of ingredients, size, and texture). The pizza was rather bland, and not too flavorful. Service was sub-par, I asked for my slices not too hot and they came out steaming hot. Do bring cash if you go, if you don’t spend over $10 with a card the surcharge is huge (over $3!). The only positive was the pizza wasn’t too pricey, slices ranged between $3 (cheese slice) to $5 (square slices). The space was also fairly large for a pizza spot, enough space and stools...