Goody's Deli
Goody's Deli things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Plan your stay
Posts
We all have our hits and misses and today was definitely not a hit for me. My wife and have been coming to goody’s for a few years now. The food is pretty good for the most part. Today we ordered a personal pizza, Ruben sandwich, and some breadsticks. We were first in line and then a bunch of people came in behind us. We ordered our food and sat down. We waited for almost 50 minutes, while in the meantime watching every person who ordered after us get their food! My wife finally went and asked them if our tickets had been misplaced or something since it was taking so long. The lady just said it would be out super soon. We then waited another 10-15 minutes before we got it at our table. When the food arrived everything tasted pretty good except for the cheese breadstick’s. They were super dry and crusty. The Ruben on the other hand had me scratching my head. ITS NOT A RUBEN!!! They basically made me a Ruben breadstick pizza! It was still good but not what I was expecting. I’ll leave a picture of it so y’all can see!😂 I definitely won’t get it again tho. The reason I’m not giving this place a one star, is because I’ve been here before and it’s usually decent. Hoping next time is better 🤞🏻
Shaun gregersenShaun gregersen
00
**update** I have reduced my rating. I went again today 5/21/2022. We had over half a pizza left and we're told we had to PAY for a box or take a PIZZA home in foil. Something about a cardboard shortage and they ran out of boxes one time so now they charge. I understand charging extra for takeout orders (most.placed do now) but to eat there and be charged to take home leftovers. I try to keep my business to local shops but after frequenting for 22years, I am done. $10 for a small pizza and the to have to pay additional to take the rest. If it was a bomb or individual, I'd be ok with foil but not half a pizza. I need to be able to carry it one handed between kids and being with someone who is at risk of falls. But my ranches we're over ¾full this time. Overall good but they charge almost $1 for 4oz container of ranch but you only get a half container, IF you're lucky.... This has happened Everytime.
Tiffany WebsterTiffany Webster
00
Pizza bomb and a sandwich delivered to our workplace for me and a coworker to split. Sandwich was the most bland, tasteless mid tier thing you could possibly imagine, like pure disappointment made edible. I honestly don't know how you even make a sandwich this bad, like....it's a sandwich, I'm already coming in with low expectations in the first place. Albertsons or Maverick make better sandwiches than this at half the price! Subway would be orders of magnitude higher than this place. The Pizza bomb was actually recommended to us by another human being (or was he?). Slightly better than the sandwich but not by much. I usually don't like to dog a place and mostly post only my positive experiences but if I can keep someone else from wasting their time with this place it will be worth it. Voted most overrated restaurant in Pocatello by me.
Frank AlbertFrank Albert
00
Nearby Attractions Of Goody's Deli
Museum of Clean
Black Swan Inn
Idaho Museum of Natural History
Bengal Theater
Idaho State University
Pocatello Model Railroad and Historical Society
My World Discovery Museum
Mountain View Cemetery
Jacksons Food Stores
Goldsmith

Museum of Clean
4.7
(380)Click for details

Black Swan Inn
4.7
(269)Click for details

Idaho Museum of Natural History
4.2
(104)Click for details

Bengal Theater
4.5
(74)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Goody's Deli
Elmer's Restaurant
Buddy's Italian Restaurant
Olivers Restaurant
Fifth Street Bagelry
The Yellowstone Restaurant
Gin Sen
Center Street Clubhouse
Portneuf Valley Brewing
Mocha Madness
Rim Rock Grill

Elmer's Restaurant
4.5
(1.1K)Click for details

Buddy's Italian Restaurant
4.4
(865)Click for details

Olivers Restaurant
4.3
(688)Click for details

Fifth Street Bagelry
4.7
(531)Click for details
Basic Info
Address
905 S 5th Ave, Pocatello, ID 83201
Map
Phone
(208) 233-9210
Call
Website
goodysdeli.com
Visit
Reviews
Overview
4.5
(533 reviews)
Ratings & Description
Description
Easygoing, simple deli offering Italian meat & veggie sandwiches, subs, pizza & salads, plus beers.
attractions: Museum of Clean, Black Swan Inn, Idaho Museum of Natural History, Bengal Theater, Idaho State University, Pocatello Model Railroad and Historical Society, My World Discovery Museum, Mountain View Cemetery, Jacksons Food Stores, Goldsmith, restaurants: Elmer's Restaurant, Buddy's Italian Restaurant, Olivers Restaurant, Fifth Street Bagelry, The Yellowstone Restaurant, Gin Sen, Center Street Clubhouse, Portneuf Valley Brewing, Mocha Madness, Rim Rock Grill
