Bagel Bar — Restaurant in Rahway

Bagel Bar 77 E. Milton Ave. Rahway, NJ 07065

Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice Lavender lemonade Rainbow Bagel with Birthday Cake Cream Cheese Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese Egg, Avocado, Tomato, Arugula, Cucumber

Located in downtown Rahway directly across the street from the Rahway train station is family owned bagel café.

Owners and sisters-in-law Karolina and Ewelina introduced me to five of the most popular breakfast menu items.

Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice: Take the name of this beverage literally. Multiple oranges are squeezed into the cup having a fair share of pulp and bursting with flavor.

In addition to this drink, there are also a variety of lemonades that are made with freshly squeezed lemons.

Lavender lemonade: It was hard to make a decision, but I ultimately went with the lavender lemonade.

This secret concoction has a purplish appearance with a natural, earthy taste.

Each of the three breakfast sandwiches I explored were served on bagels that are freshly made in house every day at 4:30 AM.

Rainbow Bagel with Birthday Cake Cream Cheese: Here is a colorful way to start the day! As soon as you take your first bite, you are going to wish your birthday was every day so you can have an excuse to always order this specialty bagel.

Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese: There is more than a fair share of taylor ham slices. The hash brown along with SPK were also great supplements to this classic sandwich!

Originally, I was hesitant to try the marble rye bagel, but the added marble blended out the rye smell giving the bagel a delicious texture.

Egg, Avocado, Tomato, Arugula, Cucumber: This is the perfect choice if you are in the mood to go vegetarian. The multiple vegetables are nutritious while still tasting delicious and the seasonings on the everything bagel provides additional flavor.

As a bonus, all customers can purchase a half dozen bagels made the previous day for a generous discount at $4.50 per bag!

It was a flawless dining experience. Special thanks to the owners and cooking crew for your fast friendly service.

#bagelbar #rahwaynj #bagels #bagelsandwich #foodstagram #lavendarlemonade #freshsqueezedlemonade #freshsqueezedorangejuice #taylorhameggandcheese #rainbowbagel...

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 10/5 Stars – The Bagle Bar is Rahway’s New Hidden Gem!

If I could give more than five stars, I would. The Bagle Bar at 77 E Milton Ave, Rahway isn’t just a bagel shop—it’s a full-on experience of warmth, flavor, and family spirit. From the second you walk in, you’re greeted like you’re part of the family. The space is cozy yet modern, with that kind of charm you can’t fake.

The bagels? Perfection. Freshly baked, with that beautiful crisp outer shell and fluffy, chewy inside. Every bite is like a love letter to breakfast. Whether you go classic with cream cheese, adventurous with their specialty spreads, or all-out with one of their epic sandwiches, you cannot go wrong.

The owners clearly pour their hearts into every detail—from the carefully sourced ingredients to the friendly smiles behind the counter. You can feel the pride they take in being a part of the Rahway community, and it makes supporting them even sweeter.

If you’re looking for your new go-to breakfast (or lunch… or snack… let’s be honest, anytime) spot, The Bagle Bar is it. Trust me, once you go, you’ll find yourself “accidentally” driving past just to stop in again.

Rahway, you’ve struck gold. Don’t walk—run to The...

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Absolutely the BEST bagel spot in Rahway! Bagel Bar is hands down my go-to place for fresh, delicious bagels and breakfast sandwiches. The bagels are always perfectly baked—soft and chewy on the inside with just the right crust—and they have so many creative flavors alongside the classics. My personal favorites are the onion, garlic, and blueberry bagels… they’re seriously next-level! All the sandwiches are loaded and full of flavor.

The staff is warm, friendly, and makes you feel like family the moment you walk in. The service is quick, the vibe is welcoming, and everything tastes fresh and made with care. Whether you’re grabbing breakfast on the go, sitting down for a weekend crepe or waffle, or just craving a perfect bagel, Bagel Bar never disappoints.

If you’re in Rahway (or even just passing through), do yourself a...