Peachey's Baking Co — Restaurant in Siesta Key

I am not exaggerating when I say that Peachey’s Baking Co. has ruined every other donut for me for the rest of my life. The chocolate ganache donut didn’t just taste good — it transported me to another dimension. I’m pretty sure I saw a bright light and heard a choir of angels while eating it. It was rich, smooth, and so perfect that I briefly considered writing it into my will.

And then… the pretzel with mustard. I don’t know what kind of culinary witchcraft they’re doing back there, but this was not just food. This was an event. I sat there, wide-eyed, clutching it like a priceless artifact. I will never look at a regular pretzel the same way again — and honestly? That’s fine.

In conclusion: if you are even thinking about going to another donut shop, don’t. Don’t waste your time. Don’t hurt yourself like that. This is it. This is the pinnacle. Everything else is just fried dough pretending to be worthy.

Peachey’s, you win. Take my money,...

My daughter picked these donuts for her birthday, and honestly, I had no idea they would be this good! I was blown away by the flavor, texture, and quality — absolutely amazing.

She asked for fresh coconut on top, and that special touch made them even better! The combo was perfect, and everyone loved them. No exaggeration: these are the best donuts I’ve had in Florida. Soft, fresh, and full of that homemade goodness. Pro tip: Get there early! They sell out quickly — and honestly, it’s really hard to resist eating them before you even get home. The best move? Grab a fresh donut and enjoy a coffee right there — it's the perfect combo! They were a hit at the celebration and became our go-to treat for any special occasion. Highly...

Best Donuts you will EVER try. First time trying this place and it’s well worth a try. From when you first walk in it’s very clean feeling and love the modern simple decor. Also it’s awesome to see the staff making the donuts fresh, very cool process to see. Ordered some donuts and an ice latte, both were delicious. The coffee is made fresh as well. I would say it’s a bit pricy here but that’s what happens when you go to places that use quality ingredients. Also, fyi the donuts are huge and very filling to just eat one lol But you most likely will eat more than one. GIVE...