Good Little Eater — Restaurant in Stillwater

This is a cute little hole-in-the-wall mom-and-pop restaurant. If you blink you might miss it! But you walk through the doors and you are instantly greeted with the smell of delicious food and the friendly and welcoming faces of the people who are filled with pride in their homemade food. All the food is cooked in-house with fresh ingredients. It is a limited menu but they change the menu every week. The seating area has 4 large tables (seating 6 each) with a small bar-like seating area. However, they are partnered with the family-friendly Stonecloud Brewery around the corner for more seating and a fun atmosphere. The environment at good little eater was very peaceful and calm. Today I got the half, grilled cheese sandwich and the absolutely delicious tomato soup. My coworkers got the pork tenderloin with maple dijon glaze and asparagus spears; a slice of sausage, pepper and cheddar quiche, tomato soup and salad, and spaghetti carbonara. Due to it being the couple's 30th Anniversary today, they were giving a free cookie with lunch orders. I got the compost cookie which is basically a kitchen sink or everything cookie, I also got a snickerdoodle crinkle cookie which was light and airy. Both were so so good. My coworkers got the lemon crinkle which was soo good and resembled real lemon, not imitation. Another got a molasses cookie which was actually moist and so so good. Reminded me of my mom's molasses cookies she makes over the holidays. Overall the service was spectacular and we didn't have to wait very long for our food. The only downside is that they have limited drink options (la Croix, coke, diet coke, water, coffee, and tea). The glass cups are by the front and are self-serve as are the silverware and napkins. Prices are a bit "pricy" in some ways but the quality of the delicious homemade food is worth the price in my opinion. They also have a freezer with various meals that you can take home and heat up during the week. This is my first time here and let's just say, I...

My wife and I chose Good Little Eater to cater our wedding and we are so, so glad we did! My mother-in-law has Celiac disease and we were able to make the entire menu gluten-free so she didn't have to be careful about what she ate. We didn't have any strong opinions on what we wanted in terms of food, so we let them put together and menu and they came up with a fantastic set of foods!

We had mushroom crostini appetizers with whipped garlic ricotta on top that the guests devoured. For dinner, they made roasted broccoli, carmelized ginger chicken, and vegetable stack (polenta, squash, eggplant, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella, and marinara). We wanted some non-cake desserts and they made pavlovas with strawberry rhubarb sauce and lemon bars, both of which were...

Wish I could have given 5 stars…food excellent atmosphere no complaints, clean inviting etc. Expensive but food is worth it, good portions. Service was absolutely dissatisfying, waited with empty glass for 20 min (I timed it), while staff played on phone and gave attention to empty tables. Was never asked how it was or if everything was ok until I was exiting establishment. I wanted to discuss service before leaving (waited a few minutes more after obviously being finished with meal)but was again ignored. Expected better service in this price range. Will give another try in near future. Hopefully my experience...