Trattoria Amalfi — Restaurant in Stonington

Trattoria Amalfi is an extraordinary Italian restaurant that has captured my heart and palate from the moment I stepped through its doors. With its warm ambiance, exceptional service, and, most importantly, the sensational flavors that transport you straight to the enchanting Amalfi Coast, this establishment deserves every one of its five stars.

From the moment you enter Trattoria Amalfi, you're welcomed by a cozy and inviting atmosphere that instantly makes you feel at home. The rustic Italian décor, soft lighting, and comfortable seating create an intimate setting that is perfect for a romantic dinner or a gathering of friends and family.

The service at Trattoria Amalfi is truly top-notch. The staff is attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable, always ready to provide recommendations and guide you through the menu. They pay attention to every detail, ensuring that your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. The waitstaff's genuine passion for the cuisine and dedication to customer satisfaction truly elevate the overall experience.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the food. Trattoria Amalfi takes Italian cuisine to new heights with their authentic dishes bursting with flavors that transport you to Italy. Each plate is a work of art, meticulously prepared and presented with an exquisite touch.

The menu offers a wide range of traditional Italian dishes, including pasta, seafood, and mouthwatering meat options. The quality of ingredients is evident in every bite. Their homemade pasta is cooked to perfection, with sauces that marry flavors harmoniously. I highly recommend trying their gnocchi and garlic bread.

The wine list at Trattoria Amalfi is extensive and curated to complement the flavors of the cuisine. The knowledgeable staff can expertly pair your meal with the perfect wine, enhancing your dining experience and allowing you to fully savor the flavors.

Trattoria Amalfi is a hidden gem that captures the essence of Italy in every aspect. From the warm and welcoming atmosphere to the attentive service and outstanding cuisine, this restaurant has set a new standard for Italian dining in the city. Whether you're a fan of Italian cuisine or simply in search of an exceptional dining experience, Trattoria Amalfi is an absolute must-visit. Prepare to embark on a culinary journey that will leave you longing to return time...

See edit below. 10/30/2024: Very allergy friendly!! I am severely allergic to dairy, nuts, and shellfish. First time, I got the grilled chicken and he got steak with Nanas sourdough bread. So good, I returned for my birthday dinner: I got rigatoni with no cheese, he got tagliatelle. Pasta is perfectly al dente, and perfect amount of spicy. Got Sicilian Mule both visits (MY FAVORITE), limoncello spritz, and amalfi lemonade. All servers are so friendly, accommodating, and knowledgeable about allergens/ingredients, but especially Kerry A. As locals, we will be back again! 5 stars for everything.

EDIT 1/6/2025: I went back a 3rd time for a family birthday. I ordered Tagliatelle without parmeseano reggiano, voiced my dairy allergy to waitress and she ensured for all allergies she notes them 3 times: on the order paper, in the computer, and vocally to the chefs. I took a bite of my pasta, had a reaction, and noticed when I mixed my pasta around it was stringy (as if there was cheese). We asked our waitress to verify that my plate was dairy-free and she was confident that there was no dairy. When we confronted her that I was experiencing a reaction and asked her to please verify with the kitchen, she apologized and finally went back to check. The manager came out and told me that the Tagliatelle was definitely not dairy free, as there is cream cooked into the bolognese sauce in the pot for hours and that the dairy in the dish does not only come from parmesean sprinkled on top. They did replace my dish with a spaghetti and marina that was allergy friendly, but the manager's tone came off as if it was my fault for ordering a dish with cheese, rather than taking responsibility. I also believe it was not JUST cream in my dish, I think there was parmesean as well since it was STRINGY! Very disappointed. Food does taste good, but please be extra careful if you have...

Staff: Every staff person we interacted with, from the hostess Paige to our server Josh, was excellent and very attentive. The young lady that cleared our dishes in between courses was nice and the gentleman that delivered our food was friendly. The manager stopped by to check on us.

Atmosphere: they did a wonderful job with the conversion from Go Fish (the restaurant that was in the space previously).

HowEVER… three out of our four entrees were terrible, which is so disappointing, b/c I really wanted to like this place! There are clearly issues with the quality of their seafood and the knowledge of the chefs behind the line.

The 1.5lb grilled lobster (menu item, not special) was leathery and had almost zero flavor. Extremely disappointing for an almost-fifty dollar plate. It came in sauce with shell crackers and a small fork but no wipes. It was very messy.

The halibut was cooked adequately (slightly overdone) but the fish itself tasted very “fishy”, which is unusual for halibut. The broccolini was fine but the asparagus was reedy and some were yellow - not fresh.

The colossal shrimp was supposed to come with a fennel salad but came out on a bed of arugula (not a big deal), but the shrimp had a very strong chemical taste (?) and was charred to within an inch of its life. In addition, it was leathery and overcooked.

And yes, we should have told the manager this, but what do you say when someone comes out, flashing all “thumbs up”, and says, “Everything is tasting great for you?”. That’s not how you ask a question you really want the answer to. We didn’t have time to send three entrees back. And, as harried moms, we were just so grateful that we didn’t have to prepare the food and wash the dishes.

If there were an issue with just one entree we’d be willing to try again but despite the excellent service and wonderful location, we...