Jeremiah's Italian Ice — Restaurant in Tallahassee

Really enjoyed my experience! Staff was very friendly the moment we walked in the door. Young man behind the counter asked if it was our first time and walked us through all their different menu options. He really did a great job of making us feel comfortable and informing us of the various different options.

I ordered a Gelati with mango and strawberry Italian ice and vanilla ice cream. It was delicious! Both the Italian ice and soft serve ice cream were high quality. My boyfriend ordered cookies and cream italian ice and really enjoyed it. The price and serving size was also really good. I got a large and paid $5.89.

We are both looking forward...

Generally I would give this location a 5 star review . Unfortunately today when I brought my family out for some Italian ice , it took way longer than usual to get our order, but this time our order came over 1/2 melted . You would have thought we ordered milkshakes . Also the young lady at the counter had a very confrontational attitude. We have never experienced this at Jeremiah’s before. Hoping the next time we come , we have our normal experience prior to today. We come once a week for a “family treat “ and would love to continue our...

Nice folks serving! As for the Italian ice itself, some of the flavors are good, and some don't have any flavor at all. I'd recommend making sure that you try the flavors you're interested in before purchasing any Italian ice. Make sure you're going to like what you get ahead of time. I loved the cookie butter the most and horchata was also delicious, but the peanut butter flavor only had the smell of peanut butter...