Cosmo & Alex Pisano Bros — Restaurant in Town of Mamaroneck

Cosmos Delicatessen - A Gem in Mamaroneck

252 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

I recently had the pleasure of experiencing Cosmos Delicatessen, and let me tell you—it’s a true gem. My first encounter there was rather unconventional. Four days ago, I found myself sitting in their outdoor seating area, casually indulging in Dunkin' coffee and donuts. Not exactly polite, I know, but the owner was all smiles and didn’t mind at all—a testament to the warm and welcoming vibe of this place.

The very next day, I decided to make amends by diving into their offerings. I grabbed a breakfast sandwich that was absolutely phenomenal—perfectly crafted, flavorful, and satisfying. I also picked up some Italian danishes to bring home for friends in Maryland, which turned out to be a massive hit.

The day after that, Terry swung by to grab some candy gifts for our Crisfield neighbors, and once again, Cosmos delivered. Their selection of Italian treats and gifts is second to none, showcasing everything from authentic deli fare to unique, high-quality goodies you won’t find elsewhere.

Beyond the fantastic food and products, the staff deserves a special mention. They’re friendly, attentive, and make every visit a pleasure. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite, stocking up on treats, or looking for the perfect gift, Cosmos Delicatessen is an absolute must-visit. This place embodies great food, great people, and a true love for their craft. Can’t wait to stop by again!

Mike and...

The assortment and presentation of the food was exactly what I wanted and expected. A throwback, 1 stop Italian shopping experience. When we walked in we told the person that was waiting on us that this was the 1st time we were there and we needed time to see what we wanted. He just kept saying that there were people waiting outside. I'm not one to keep others waiting, but I looked and there was no one on line waiting to come in. It's not that we were dawdling, there's a lot to see. He rushed us for no reason. I probably would have bought more, but he made me feel like I was wasting his time. We bought some prepared foods and if they're good I'll give them another try, if not there always A&S. Their food is good and they're friendly. BTW, I checked as we left, there was still no one...

Food is good and I also buy my olive oil here. However, do not go here between the hours of 11:00am and 1:30pm. It basically turns into a sandwich making shop during those hours. Long line of working guys buying lunch sandwiches and it takes forever to get waited on. On a few occasions, I was trying to buy some items (olive oil, bread, cheese, etc.). Impossible to get waited on as all the staff were making sandwiches. The wait was ridiculous. They should have at least one cashier for regular customers not looking for a...