Goldberg's Famous Bagels — Restaurant in Town of Southold

The bagels are EXCEPTIONAL! I would highly recommend ordering in advance if you can to pick it up. We ordered a platter for 11 of mixed bagels and various spreads, and it was devoured!

The only thing that dropped this review to 4 out of 5 stars was that at 8:30 AM, we ordered sandwiches for lunch to pick up 2 hours later. The sandwiches had not even begun preparation at 10:30 when we arrived and so it was delayed by another hour. That experience wasn't great, and the sandwiches themselves were not great either. I think their expertise is...

Warning not for people with gluten allergies. I ordered a gluten free bagel that was dry, burnt and without flavor, they refused a refund on a bagel that costed me $7.99 (cream cheese is $5.99). The farm fresh omelet was barely edible and came without the advertised avocado they refused to fix just refunded $2 for the avocado. The hash browns were McDonald’s quality and shockingly flavorless. I paid over $27 dollars for a breakfast that was mediocre at best but totally inedible if you like quality food. I suggest going somewhere else if you...

While this is part of the Goldberg's Famous Bagels chain, this store has good bagels although not the best that we had while we were in Long Island. My benchmark is an everything bagel and I have to say that these folks make a really good everything seasoning blend. The bagels themselves are good but not spectacular. The crust was OK, but not crackly and crumb was a little too doughy and not chewy enough. The egg and bacon and the HOBO sandwiches were otherwise very tasty and enjoyable. Certainly a good bagel and...