Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe of Newburgh — Local services in Newburgh

Very disappointed . We prepaid for our large order for our family reunion and made three trips to confirm the order prior to our event today. When we arrived at agreed time to take hot food directly to reunion , they did not have order ready and acted like they didn’t know about order. The food was not warm. What a mess for us. Then we were lied too when we asked if everything was there and was told yes it’s all there. We ordered brisket , Chicken and pork. There was no brisket . We had to call them out on the missing brisket. The food was good but the idea of ordering a meal catered and the stress that was caused is uncalled for. Just be honest mistakes happen but own them . Lots of BBQ catering in area you might want to avoid...

Excellent! I am so glad the Old Fashioned Butcher Shoppe has opened in Warrick County! Now I can find an excellent choice of the best meats close to home! They have the additional bonus of offering special order BBQ meats and meal on Saturdays! YUMMMM! The barbecue is off the charts! This weekend we bought the smoked turkey breast and pulled pork. They both were absolutely melt in your mouth. Last weekend we got the ribs and the brisket. The ribs were a perfect combination of sweet and spicy with all the tenderness you could ask for! I have never been a brisket fan, but this brisket was tender, tasty and cooked to perfection. It changed my mind about brisket. We highly recommend the Old Fashioned Butcher...

Great prices on great cuts of meat the tri-tip i purchased smoked beautifully tender melt in your mouth the wings were large and well priced as well as great butterflyed chops perfect for grilling will be my choice for meat from now on professional staff super clean and plenty of selections of meat amd cuts to choose from it was truly a pleasure to come into a establishment that has pride in the product that they provide with the attitude to serve a customer quickly with plenty of information on the meats also supporting other small local people with the products on the shelf love seeing small buisness staying in a family if you havent been here you are...