Scarborough Fair Prepared Foods & Catering — Local services in Town of Eastchester

I couldn’t have better things to say. I had a baby shower catered for 10 people and everything ran so smoothly. Rentals showed up a day before and were set up where asked, the crew was here on time and was incredibly professional (and more helpful/involved than I expected!), and the food was wonderful. Coordinating with JB was also so easy - always to the point and quick to reply. And the cherry on top was they left absolutely 0 mess - once we moved the rentals, it didn’t even look like it we had a party. I've heard horror stories with caterers and this was a literal dream. I also found their pricing to be very fair, and they found ways to work with us to keep the costs down (very much an a la carte service vs having to purchase a “package”). Could not recommend them...

We ordered the skirt steak family dinner with butternut squash ravioli, roasted potatoes, field green salad with gorgonzola and tiramisu for dessert. Everything was absolutely delicious!! The steak melted in your mouth, was seasoned perfectly. The heating instructions allow you to cook the steak from rare to well done. I served the ravioli first as an appetizer and it was such an elegant presentation! The roasted potatoes were amazing and the salad was gourmet and the tiramisu bakery fresh. It was an incredible value to throw an elegant dinner party, delivered right to your front door, with the preparation being very little effort on my part. This allowed me to focus on my guests!! Cannot wait to...

Mixed experience with this company. Ordered catering for a party. One of the item was missed from the order but the owner made up for it and re-delivered the missing item on time -- that's wonderful. Food was OK (3.5-4 stars). However the reason this review is only two stars is because many of the attendees got sick the next day (some sort of stomach virus). I cannot guarantee that it was the food from Scarborough Fair that caused the illness, but it was the only thing we all had in common (guests travelled from various locations). What made matters worse is that when I told them about the experience (politely, I did not request any sort of reimbursement or anything) they...