Fedele Amicos pizzeria — Restaurant in Douglasville

UPDATED February 17th, 2025: I returned today, February to give it another go around. I ordered wings and a slice of pizza. The wings were cool. The pizza? Ughhhh...keeps getting worse. I have uploaded photos of my slice of pizza from today. Got home and picked up the slice to eat it. BURNT. DRY. ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE. Why would you sell anyone a burnt pizza??? It tasted BURN , as it was BURNT. I am officially done here. What a rip off. Very disappointed and discouraged. I don't have money or time to waste. Didn't even bother calling, because I was not about to turn around and drive 20 minutes back to the restaurant to return the pizza slice to get a refund or another slice.

ORIGINAL REVIEW BELOW APPROXIMATELY APRIL 2024: I've been coming here well over a year now. The pizza used to be so good!!! Now not so much. The pizza doesn't have a bit of sauce anymore and barely any cheese. I have asked for extra sauce and there still isn't any sauce. Driest pizza ever now. There is minimal flavor and the crust is like cardboard. It was awful. Yuck. Some of the wing flavors are okay and others don't taste good at all. Last few experiences have been a waste of money. We will not be returning. The formula is definitely off. I am guessing they are cutting corners like every other establishment , meanwhile the quality of food goes down and then the number of customers. The owner is sweet and has attempted to make orders right when they have messed up. That doesn't change the quality and taste of the...

WoW - so close to NY Pie - so let me start by saying what a welcoming - real- and honest establishment - this was our first time ordering from Fedele Amicos - we saw the reviews 4.8 - we decided let's try them - we called in on Thursday evening and expressed we would like to see about placing an order and how many days in advance do they need - the young lady I spoke with expressed at least 2 days well we placed our order so we could have the pizza by Saturday - our granddaughter's 1 year old birthday party was on 7/22/2023 - we wanted pizza as with most individuals who have kid parties - we ordered 3 of each: meat, pep, cheese, and supreme - when I tell you EveryOne enjoyed and raved about this pizza would be an understatement - it was phenomenal- you can tell the pizza was made from scratch and with a lot of love - my family and I have a NEW pizza go to spot - you will not go wrong when ordering from Fedele - the owner the crew take pride in what they do and do not skimp on toppings - thank you Fedele Amicos for having an establishment who still provides wonderful customer service and food worth paying and waiting for - if you want pizza the way it is meant to be made, enjoyed, and savored "Fedele Amicos" is the spot - Many continued...

Love Love Love Fedele Amicos Pizza! Amazing customer service and order is ready super fast. The $5 pizza delicious and an amazing deal... and the wings are HUGE! The pizza tastes like REAL pizza, not that chain restaurant mess. Just enough cheese and plenty of toppings... Have I mentioned that the pizza is WAAAY better than that other place that sells $5 pizzas!? Our order of 15 wings barely fit in a standard take out box, that's how big they are! I don't typically do baked wings because they are usually slimey and just yucky but bayy-bay when I say these were the BEST baked wings I have ever had, I mean it. These wings were crispy and cooked to perfection. Thankfully my hubby will eat wings from just about anywhere and requested that we try them or I would have missed out! Also, they currently have a special from 5pm - 8pm where the wings are only .75 a piece! This may be a tiny little take out pizzeria in an older shopping center right in the construction mess that we all know as Fairburn Rd but don't sleep on Fedele Amico's Pizzeria, you're missing...